F1000Research F1000Research 2046-1402 F1000 Research Limited London, UK 10.12688/f1000research.17543.1 Systematic Review Articles Preparedness components of health systems in the Eastern Mediterranean Region for effective responses to dust and sand storms: a systematic review

[version 1; peer review: 2 approved]

 Allahbakhshi Kiyoumars Conceptualization Data Curation Formal Analysis Investigation Methodology Project Administration Validation Visualization Writing – Original Draft Preparation Writing – Review & Editing https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7152-0722 1 Khorasani-Zavareh Davoud Conceptualization Data Curation Formal Analysis Investigation Methodology Project Administration Supervision Validation Visualization Writing – Original Draft Preparation Writing – Review & Editing 1 2 3 Jazani Reza Khani Conceptualization Methodology Writing – Original Draft Preparation Writing – Review & Editing 1 Ghomian Zohreh Conceptualization Data Curation Formal Analysis Methodology Project Administration Supervision Validation Visualization Writing – Original Draft Preparation Writing – Review & Editing a 1 Department of Health in Disasters and Emergencies, School of Public Health and Safety, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran Clinical Sciences and Education Department, Karolinska Institute, Stockholm, Sweden Safety Promotion and Injury Prevention Research Center, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran zghomian@sbmu.ac.ir

No competing interests were disclosed.

 4 2 2019 2019 8 146 21 1 2019 Copyright: © 2019 Allahbakhshi K et al. 2019 This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Licence, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Background: Dust and Sand Storms (DSS), according to estimates by global reports, will increase dramatically in the Eastern Mediterranean Region (EMR). Numerous health problems caused by DSS will be severely affected regions and vulnerable groups. This study aimed to identify the components of the preparedness of health systems for the DSS phenomenon in EMR.

Methods:In this systematic review, the peer-reviewed papers in four electronic databases, including Medline through PubMed, Scopus, ISI Web of Science and the Cochrane library, as well as available grey literature, were searched and selected. The research process was carried out by including papers whose results were related to the potential health effects caused by desert dusts in EMR. Was used the combination of three groups of keywords: the exposure factor, health effects as outcomes, and the countries located in EMR. The focus was on the PRISMA checklist, with no time limitations until December 2017. Finally, through 520 related citations, 30 articles were included. Descriptive and thematic content analyses were evaluated.

Results: The preparedness components were divided into three and ten main categories and subcategories, respectively. The three categories covered the areas of DSS hazard identification, planning and policy-making, and risk assessment.

Conclusions: Recognition of the health system preparedness factors for DSS in EMR will help policy-makers and managers perform appropriate measures when dealing with this hazard. More studies should be conducted to understand these factors in other parts of the world.

Registration: PROSPERO registration number CRD42018093325.

 dust and sand storm health preparedness reediness Eastern Mediterranean Region The author(s) declared that no grants were involved in supporting this work. Introduction

Dust and Sand Storms (DSS), as a natural disaster from the type of meteorological hazards 1, 2 , affects the atmospheric system, air quality, and human health 3– 6 . Over the recent years, the review studies have shown that there is a relation between the occurrence of the DSS and the incidence of human health 7, 8 .

Based on the division by the World Health Organization (WHO), there are 22 countries in the Eastern Mediterranean Region (EMR) 9 . According to estimates from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) report, EMR is one of the areas that will be strongly affected by this phenomenon in the future and will have potentially harmful health effects, especially on vulnerable groups 10, 11 . Therefore, the best way to minimize the damage caused by the disasters is the preparedness for them 12 . The constant increasing risk of hazards indicates the need to integrate disaster risk reduction in preparedness, reinforce disaster preparedness, and provide assurance for timely utilization of the capacities 13 .

The epidemiological studies conducted on DSS mainly focus on the effects of the phenomenon on mortality and morbidity in humans 14– 20 or on the nature of major sources of dust phenomenon, the frequency, the duration and changes to the occurrence of the DSS, and the content of particulate matter (PM) suspended in the air 8 . Considering the DSS challenges on human health, drastic measures should be taken to ensure the health system is prepared for this phenomenon. In this regard, important elements have been proposed in the health system preparedness for disasters including the identification of hazards, the provision of Emergency Operation Plan (EOP), training and education, equipment, Early Warning System (EWS), information exchange, drill and exercise, monitoring, and evaluation 13, 21– 28 . On the other hand, there has not been a comprehensive study on the factors affecting the preparedness of the health system for dust phenomenon in EMR. Accordingly, the present study, through systematic review (SR), aims to investigate the factors affect the health system preparedness for the DSS in EMR and identify research gaps on the preparedness of the health system for DSS. The findings of the study, with proposed recommendations, can directly help health policymakers in preparedness promotion for this phenomenon, pave the way for further studies, and add to the richness of the current knowledge.

 Methods

This study reports a SR based on the recommendations of the Cochrane and PRISMA guideline 29 . The PROSPERO registration number is CRD42018093325. A completed PRISMA checklist is available on figshare 30 .

Inclusion and exclusion criteria

All English-language articles related to effective factors on the preparedness of the health system for dust phenomenon in EMR were searched until December 2017. All methods of study, books, and theses that associated with the subject of this research were included. Papers in the form of the letter to the editor and studies that were merely related to the dust subject, and in which no mention of health outcome, were excluded, as were non-English-language articles, as were those without full-text access. Additionally, scientific documents related to non-desert origin (such as volcanic or anthropogenic sources) were not included.

 Data sources

The international electronic databases investigated by authors (KA, ZGH, DKZ), including English sources from Medline through PubMed, Scopus, ISI web of science, Google Scholar, Cochrane library. The Eastern Mediterranean Health Journal and African Journals OnLine were also searched for published articles in the EMR. Other documents were extracted from reports published by organizations (such as the United Nations).

 Search strategy

Following consultations with Library & Information Science (LIS) professionals in the health field, the search for articles was done using a combination of three groups of words in the databases mentioned above: The exposure factor (Dust Storm OR Sand Storm OR desert dust), health effects as outcomes (health OR morbidity OR mortality OR disease OR hospital OR respiratory OR cardiovascular OR coccidiomycosis OR meningococcal meningitis OR conjunctivitis OR dermatological OR transport accidents), and member states of the EMR (Middle East OR Afghanistan OR Bahrain OR Djibouti OR Egypt OR Iran OR Iraq OR Jordan OR Kuwait OR Lebanon OR Libyan Arab Jamahiriya OR Morocco OR Oman OR Pakistan OR Occupied Palestinian Territory OR Qatar OR Saudi Arabia OR Somalia OR Sudan OR Syrian Arab Republic OR Tunisia OR United Arab Emirates OR Yemen). These three groups of words were combined with "AND" together. The keywords were obtained from previous articles relating to the challenges of the health domain in connection with the DSS. In order to increase the probability of identification of all relevant literature, these keywords were selected based on an agreement of three researchers (KA, ZGH, and DKZ). The search words are used in titles, abstracts, and keywords of used articles. Figure 1 shows the search strategy.

PRISMA flowchart to extract effective components on the preparedness of the health systems for DSS in the EMR until December 2017. Data collection process

In order to manage the citations, EndNote software, version X15, was used. All duplicate records became clear and removed. Using the title, abstract and, keywords screening, and given the inclusion criteria, the evaluation of documents was performed by two researchers (KA and ZGH). In the next step, the full text of the remaining articles was analyzed independently by the two researchers considering the inclusion and exclusion criteria and standard quality assessment. The papers were later examined in order to observe the points of the criteria for inclusion/exclusion by two other scholars (DKZ and RKJ). The quality of all articles was evaluated using the Cochrane handbook to evaluate the bias ( Table 1) 31 . In this SR, the data extraction sheet was designed in two main parts. The first section covers the general specification of articles containing the ID, hyperlinks, title, electronic database, first author, publication year, country or region, method, population, and year/years of study. The second part was used to identify the main findings of articles, research suggestions related to this SR, and the preparedness components of the health system for the DSS. All extracted data were evaluated by members of the research team to verify accuracy and completeness.

Different types of reporting biases in the SR of preparedness components of health systems in the EMR for effective response in DSS.
Type of reporting bias Bias assessment across studies were done in this SR
Publication bias During the quality assessment, checked that have included two abstracts of the articles 32, 33 presented at conferences, which have been published fully later. In this SR grey literatures (n= 206) and peer review articles (n = 314) included in the study. Were also considered studies with positive (n=27) and negative (n=5) outcomes. Two articles have both outcomes. It is important to note that access to full texts of some articles was limited (n = 16); however, after reading the abstract the research team found that most of them did not have related information about the aim of our systematic review.
Time lag bias For positive and negative outcomes, the average per month, between submissions to published, was investigated that it took 4.5 and 3, respectively. However, in this process, different factors can play a role.
Multiple (duplicate) publication bias The inclusion of multiple publications of the same study was checked within this SR; eventually, and no case found.
Location bias The citations published in the journals, with various Impact Factors (IF) (non – IF to IF= 4.61), were evaluated. The studies with IF is less than one and non - IF as well as the articles with IF more than one were (n = 10, 33 %) and (n= 20, 67 %), respectively. The purpose of this study was concentrated primarily on the EMR. Therefore, Only articles in this area were reviewed.
Citation bias In this SR, the research team tried to take into account the inclusion criteria when using other related references. Also, were included both positive and negative outcomes to the SR.
Language bias One of the inclusion criteria for this SR was the English language. We did not have the possibility of translating other non - English languages, and this was the limitation of the study.
Outcome reporting bias Given the objective of this SR, there was no possibility of exploring this type of bias. No RCT included to the SR.
Results

In general, through the implementation of the research strategy, the number of 520 records was found. In the last stage, 30 unique articles were obtained based on the inclusion/exclusion criteria ( Figure 1). Data on the risk evaluation of bias are provided in Table 1. Final articles were examined in two parts, including descriptive and thematic content analysis. In Table 2, more details are presented about the imported literature to the SR. Findings indicate that since 2008, researchers have published more articles about the effects of the DSS on public health. Most articles related to Iran (17 articles, 56%). None of them had a qualitative approach. In thematic content analysis, based on literature review of studies that identify factors affecting the health system preparedness for various hazards 21– 28 and the multistage analysis by the research group, the preparedness components of health system for DSS in EMR were extracted and classified ( Table 3).

Selected articles in the SR on the factors affecting the preparedness of the health systems for the DSS in the EMR.
Related reference First author, year Country District/national/ international/ level Study design Population Main outcomes
34 Geravandi S., 2017 Iran District Descriptive study data of hospital admission respiratory patients and dusty days Hospital admission cases were significantly higher during the dusty days compared to other days (p = 0.0002).
47 Shabankarehfard E., 2017 Iran District matched case-control study 45 cases of allergic patients and 45 in the control group Penicillium and Alternaria (available in outdoor dusts), as well as Aspergillus flavus and Cladosporium (available in indoor dusts), cause allergic diseases. On the other hand, the Alternaria in the homes has a significant adverse association with asthma prevalence.
35 Naimabadi A., 2016 Iran District Cross-sectional study/ laboratory study 15 PM10 filters for normal days and 15 PM10 filters in the dusty days In dusty days, the increase of the metal concentration in the dust was more than other days.
36 Neisi A., 2017 Iran District Cross-sectional study 110 non-asthmatic elementary school students Researchers by comparing the Fractional exhaled nitric oxide (FENO) and pulmonary functions as parameters of adverse health effects caused by PM have found that there is a significant association between PM concentration and FENO in healthy students.
57 Hosseini G., 2015 Iran District Cross-sectional study/ laboratory analysis The number of samples belonging to non - dusty days and dusty days were 44 cases and 9 cases, respectively. During the dusty days, the main elements contained in PM10 included (Na, Ca, Mg, Al, Fe).
45 Ebrahimi S. J. A., 2014 Iran District Cross-sectional study The data associated with the PM10 concentration and air quality as well as the data from the cardiovascular and respiratory disease associated with dust The PM10 concentration for every 100 μg \ m 3, was found to be the significant statistical correlation with (cardiovascular disease) and non - significant statistical correlation with (respiratory problems).
37 Khaniabadi Y. O., 2017 Iran District Cross-sectional study PM10 samples obtained from air pollution monitoring stations 4.7% and 4.2% of the hospital admission cases were the cardiovascular and respiratory patients associated with the PM10 concentration of up to 10 μg \ m 3, respectively.
38 Amarloei A., 2015 Iran District Cross-sectional study Selection of 250 persons and in the next stage random cluster sampling from 13 health centers According to the values of breathing capacities, 21.6% of the participants suffered from obstructive lesions. It was in men more than women.
49 Moradian M.J., 2015 Iran District brief incident report Citizens of Tehran In general, a total of 5 deaths and 44 injuries caused by the dust storm. Other damages included floating debris, knocked down trees, car accident, temporary shutdown of (electricity, Internet and telephone), delay in flights and damage to the structures.
55 Nourmoradi H., 2015 Iran District Cross-sectional study/ laboratory analysis PM10's daily sampling was carried out at a site of the city. Every 7 days and dusty days, Microbial sampling has been performed. The PM10 concentration in May, June, and July (twice a month) was higher than standard values. The average number of bacteria and fungi in the air during the dusty days was (1.5 and 3.83 times) the non-dusty days. During the dust period, the most abundant type of bacteria and fungi observed in the samples, respectively, are due to (Bacillus spp and Mycosporium spp.).
39 Thalib L., 2012 Kuwait National population-based retrospective time series study 15256 emergency asthma and respiratory patient as well as PM10 data from 6 air monitoring stations. Around 33.6% of the days was the dust storm (PM10> 200 μg / m 3). These days significantly related to an increase in emergency admission of asthmatic and respiratory patients on the same day. Based on the findings, were about 4% to 8% of all respiratory cases associated with DSS, most of which were children.
18 Al-Taiar A., 2014 Kuwait National population based retrospective ecological time series study death cases and data of dusty days and air pollution (569 days) of 6 air pollution monitoring stations There was no statistically significant correlation between the occurrence of DSS and respiratory death.
44 Bener A., 1996 UAE District Cross-sectional study 850 school children (6 to 14 years) DSS cause asthma among students.
40 Marzouni M.B., 2016 Iran District Cross-sectional study PM10 hourly data 7.6, 11, 15.1, 13.5, and 7.6% of TM, CM, RM, HARD, and HACD were related to short-term exposure with PM10.
46 Soleimani Z., 2013 Iran District Cross-sectional study Sampling from three sites (school, university, and hospital) in three seasons, 264 times during the non-dusty days and 66 times in the dust days, was carried out. The concentration of fungi (Cladosporium, Alternaria, Aspergillus, Penicillium, Rhizopus) during the dusty days was more than the other days. Aspergillus was dominant in summer and autumn and Cladosporium in the winter. In the morning, the high concentration of fungus was observed.
32 Miri A., 2007 Iran District Cross sectional study Synoptic stations weather data and 150 questionnaires The main problem of patients in dust days is respiratory disorders (COPD and asthma). These respiratory problems brought economic losses to about US $ 66 million.
33 Meibodi A.E., 2015 Iran and Iraq Regional Mixed method (literature survey and cooperative games theory and Shapley solution) NA The total estimated losses from DSS to the health system in Iran and Iraq amounted to the US $306 million, respectively. The total losses in the two countries were estimated at the US $1043 and the US $1404 million, respectively.
50 Almasi A., 2016 Iran District Cross-sectional study PM10 concentration data and death data due to traffic accidents By increasing the dust concentration were reduced traffic accidents.
41 Goudarzi G., 2017 Iran District Cross sectional study PM10 samples obtained from air pollution stations The number of excess cases estimated to respiratory death, hospital admission of COPD patients, respiratory and cardiovascular diseases attributed to the PM10 concentration, were 37, 39, 476 and 184, respectively. Also, 92% of the deaths and disease cases occurred in the days when the concentration of PM10 was less than 150 μg / m 3.
56 Soleimani Z., 2016 Iran District Cross sectional study From different parts of the hospital, measured samples of air. Dominant bacteria in open and closed environments during dusty days and other days were (Bacillus spp., Micrococcus spp., Streptomyces spp., and Staphylococcus spp.).
42 Al-Dabbas M.A., 2012 Iraq Provincial Cross sectional study The dust samples collected from 8 cases of DSS as well as the weather data of 44 stations. The most common types of bacteria were Bacillus and E.Coli, respectively. Also, the most common types of fungi were Aspergillus and C. Albicans, respectively. In the samples, no viruses were found. The most important pollens were Chenopodiaceous and Graminea.
52 Metcalf J., 2012 Qatar Provincial Cross sectional study/ Laboratory analysis soil samples weighing one kilogram The existence of microcystins and potentially anatoxin-a (S) in the desert pollens have effects on human health.
51 Richer R., 2015 Qatar District Cross sectional study Examples of desert soil In the impact of human exposure and inhalation of contaminated dust with Cyanobacterial toxins, health consequences can be found.
48 Alghamdi M.A., 2016 Saudi Arabia District Cross sectional study/ Laboratory analysis Samples of environmental PM on the sampling site Fe and Al were the most dominant metal in the PM10. The values of Ni and Cd were higher than global standards. The results of the study showed that 108.77 out of anyone million people are at risk of cancer after exposure to carcinogenic heavy metal in the environment.
53 Alangari A.A., 2015 Saudi Arabia District Cross sectional study Children aged 2 – 12, referral to hospital No correlation between the daily average (PM10 and PM2. 5) and the average number of asthmatic children did not find.
68 Ardalan A., 2016 Iran National Cross sectional study 421 hospital in the country As the first ten hazards in hospitals, according to HSI assessment in 2015, DSS (59%) after the earthquake (71%), and high temperatures (64%) were identified.
66 Ardalan A., 2014 Iran National Cross sectional study 224 hospitals nationwide According to HSI, disasters with the highest probability of occurrence and effects were the earthquake (68%), DSS (62%), and high temperature (58%).
64 Ardalan A., 2013 Iran National Retrospective survey 1401 PHC at the country Among all types of natural hazards, the frequency of DSS and its effects on PHC was: Hazard frequency (2.5%), the impact on health workers (1.6%), the structural damage (0.9%), non - structural damage (0.7%), and functional damage (6.1%).
17 Khaniabadi Y.O., 2017 Iran District Ecological study Air pollution data 4.9% of the hospital visits for COPD and 7.3% of the RM attributed to an increase of 10 μg/m 3 of PM10 concentration. There is a direct relationship between increasing PM10 concentrations, to more than 200 μg /m 3, at the time of MED and the hospitalization rate.
65 Shaw R., 2016 Iran National Country status report and case study NA Establishment of DuSNIFF is an initiative measure in the prediction of DSS.

TM, Total Mortality; CM, Cardiovascular Mortality; RM, Respiratory Mortality; HARD, Hospital Admission for Respiratory Diseases; HACD, Hospital Admission for Cardiovascular Diseases; PHC, Primary Health Centers; DuSNIFF, Dust Storm Network-based Integrated System of Forecast and Forewarning.

 Preparedness components of health systems for DSS in EMR.
Main category Category Subcategory Extracted from Citation
Study results Study recommendations
DSS preparedness components DSS Hazard identification Health problems caused by DSS * N.A 17, 18, 34– 54
Composition of DSS * N.A 35, 42, 46– 48, 51, 52, 55– 59
Economic losses on health * N.A 32, 33
Planning and policymaking Education and training * * 17, 36, 49, 60
Research N.A * 18, 35, 37, 39, 43, 52– 55, 57, 61
Compilation of new and local indexes of air quality N.A * 61
Comprehensive database development N.A * 57, 64
Prediction and warning * * 49, 53, 65
Risk Assessment Use of hospital safety assessment tools N.A * 66, 68
Use models for health risk assessment of DSS N.A * 18, 39, 69

NA, not applicable.

 DSS hazard identification

Health problems caused by DSS. Studies conducted in EMR showed that the prevalence of respiratory diseases (RD) 17, 34– 43 and respiratory mortality (RM) is directly related to DSS 17, 40, 41 . Some of these studies focused on the incidence of asthma and pulmonary dysfunction in schoolchildren 44 . On the other hand, dust storms result in hospitalization due to cardiac diseases 37, 40, 41, 45 and cardiac mortalities (CM) 40 . Some of the various fungal species in EMR dust storms cause infectious diseases in human beings 46 that increase or decrease allergic and asthma diseases 47 . Exposure to carcinogenic metals in PM10 increases the risk of cancer in citizens 48 . Other problems reported by the researchers were death and trauma due to the occurrence of storms (at a speed of 110 km/h) with dust particles 49 . Researchers found that as the concentration of DSS increases, the death caused by road traffic accidents (RTAs) decreases 50 . Studies conducted in Qatar showed that inhaling cyanotoxins found in DSS could have devastating effects on human health 51, 52 . In contrast to these results, a number of researchers found that in general DSS had no effect on asthma, RD, RM 18, 45, 53 , CM 18 , and RTAs 54 .

Composition of DSS. The most abundant of bacteria observed in the dust particles were Bacillus spp. 42, 55, 56 , Staphylococcus spp., Streptomyces spp., Micrococcus spp. 56 and Escherichia coli 42 . Also, most types of fungi were ( Mycosporium spp. 55 Penicillium, Aspergillus flavus, Cladosporium, Alternaria, Rhizopus, and Cladosporium) 46, 47 , C. albicans 42 . The pollen grains caused allergies, identified from dust storms, in descending order, included Chenopodiaceous, Graminea, Pine, Artemisia, Palmae, Olea, and Typha 42 . No viruses were found in the dust particle samples 42 . On the other hand, the studies showed that the concentration of metals in dust increases in dusty days 35 . The main elements contained in the PM10 include (Na, Ca, Mg, Al, Fe) 48, 57 . Among the carcinogenic metals in PM10 are Ni, Cr, As, and Cd 57 . According to studies conducted in Jordan and Saudi Arabia, dust samples contained considerable amounts of radioactivity 58, 59 . Among other compounds reported in the desert dust are cyanobacteria toxins 51, 52 .

Economic losses on health. The economic losses caused by the respiratory problems in Zabol, Iran, are estimated at about US$66 million 32 . The total damage estimated from DSS to the health system in Iran and Iraq amounted to US$306 million 33 .

 Planning and policymaking

Education and training. The researchers emphasized that there should be health care recommendations for all affected individuals by DSS to reduce the vulnerability of population at risk, especially susceptible groups such as older persons, children, and cardiovascular and respiratory patients 17, 36, 60 . Also, providing community-based training is an important role in the proper functioning of the people after receiving a warning message related to DSS 49 .

Research. Scientific findings focused on this issue that further epidemiological studies should be conducted to identify chemical compounds and microorganisms in PM10, the baseline incidence values for each country, and the potential effects of DSS on health, especially long-term effects 18, 35, 37, 39, 43, 52– 55, 57, 61 . Moreover, there was no qualitative research among the studies reviewed.

Compilation of new and local indexes of air quality. Based on the assessment of PM-related health risks, researchers found that it is necessary to design new standards for local ambient air quality in the EMR 61, 62 . Only limited countries such as Saudi Arabia, Bahrain and Jordan have an air pollution index relevant to their country 61, 63 .

Comprehensive database development. To sum up the studies, provision of a comprehensive database of air pollutants and the effects of natural hazards, such as DSS, on health facilities is crucial for the benefit of policymakers and people 57, 64 .

Prediction and warning. Based on the findings of the studies conducted in EMR, the deployment of EWS such as the network-based integrated system of forecast and forewarning (DuSNIFF) can be a good base and framework for a timely warning to the population at risk 49, 65 . Conversely, other researchers reported that there is no need for a warning to the emergency department of hospitals in the event of DSS occurrence 53 .

 Risk assessment

Use of hospital safety assessment tools. According to the assessment of Farsi Hospital Safety Index (FHSI), as a preparedness tool 66, 67 , during different years in Iran, DSS was assessed as one of the highest probability of occurrence and health effects 68 .

Use models for health risk assessment of DSS. Based on the studies, health policymakers can find a better understanding of the health effects associated with PM10 peak times by using the findings of analytic models such as AirQ 69 and generalized additive model (GAM) 18, 39 .

 Discussion

Preparedness for DSS in large-scale management and at the community level is one of the essential measures in the EMR. Provision of the necessary information such as the burden of diseases caused by DSS can be used in policy-making to focus on pre-disaster planning such as preparedness. The Hyogo Framework for Action (HFA) as an international strategy put emphasis on preparedness in order to produce effective response measures at all levels, to prioritize disaster risk reduction, and to reduce the background risk factors 70 . Preparedness needs to be preserved and dynamic and ongoing efforts 21 . Conducting research and producing scientific evidence relevant to disease burdens resulting from DSS can help to improve the health system preparedness for DSS 71 . Given that health disorders caused by climate change affect the pattern and changing the burden of disease in the community, therefore, having basic guidelines on preparedness will make optimal use of resources in health service delivery 72, 73 . The health managers in EMR must develop their readiness based on the recognition of the burden of acute and long-term diseases and different dimensions of phenomenon. DSS preparedness requires a clear understanding and assessment of the country's situation. Health centers also need to be prepared regarding the personnel, equipment, medicine, and infrastructure.

The trained people that have greater understanding are more aware of the risks of hazards and in the event of a disaster, they act more appropriately 74, 75 . One of the top priorities of the Sendai Framework for disaster risk 2015–2030 is the understanding of disasters in all their dimensions to allow appropriate measures to be taken for disaster preparedness. This framework is the result of consultations and intergovernmental negotiations that were encouraged by the United Nations Office for Disaster Risk Reduction 13 . Training, as one of the effective factors in the promotion of a disaster-preparedness culture, is essential in two levels: community-based education and training of health providers. Planning and doing regular drills in various scales is essential for the promotion of general and specialized education levels of the organizations and the people affected by this phenomenon. To enhance the understanding of disaster risk among managers and the community, awareness-raising programs should focus on capacity development through sharing previous experiences and lessons about preparedness for DSS. Also, the development of indigenous knowledge should be considered. For instance, in desert area, and not available to a mask, using of keffiyeh 76, 77 is recommended for protection from DSS.

With the purpose of planning for preparedness, regional policymakers must consider local considerations when using air quality indexes. Tsiouri et al. 63 and Murena 78 noted that different geographical regions have specific climatic conditions; therefore, this issue has an impact on atmospheric pollutants that affect human health as well as population responses to air pollution. As a result, the localization and adaptation of air pollution and its indicators can take place throughout the world. With the purpose of planning for preparedness, regional policymakers have to take into account that cannot be ignored local considerations when using air quality indexes 63, 78 . To reduce the concerns, in light of valid regional evidence, the use of these standards should be reviewed.

Some studies in EMR 18, 45, 50, 53, 54 and other regions of the world have shown that there is no association between the occurrence of dust and increasing health problems 79– 82 . However, it is important to conclude that with increasing frequency, intensity and geographic expansion of DSS, it is necessary to ensure a timely and valid warning to vulnerable populations and groups 16, 83 . Provision of advanced and accurate warning systems requires continuous efforts to improve air quality modeling and prediction 73 . Moreover, the results of various studies in the world show that early health warnings to vulnerable people about air pollution can reduce emergency visits to health centers through the reduction of outdoor activity during dusty days 16, 83 .

The trans-boundary nature of DSS, unlike many natural hazards, is not limited to a specific geographic area; therefore, regional cooperation is needed to prepare for this phenomenon. In this regard, Kuwaiti scholars have suggested that it is essential to establish a regional committee 54 . The health system of the countries involved in DSS give priority to the development of regional health memorandums of understanding (MoU). In the framework of these MoUs, countries can strengthen regional and global collaboration as with UN and WMO to transfer modern technologies for prediction of DSS occurrences, exchange of medical knowledge, allocation of financial and technical assistance, combat against desertification, share of information and successful practical experiences, to form a regional credit union, and to build training workshops.

Strengths and limitations of the study

It can be noted, among the strengths of this study, the literature analysis performed with carefully assessing and have been done several times by the research team. Their research area was about Health in Disasters and Emergencies. The focus of this SR was on the EMR, as one of the most challenging areas, which has large DSS sources and creates regional health problems. A comprehensive study with this goal, so far, has not been conducted in this region. However, in this SR, only English articles related to EMR were included, the number of articles related to dust and health field was limited, and the full text of some studies was not accessible.

 Conclusion

The burden of diseases caused by dust in EMR shows the need to undertake measures for government preparedness to protect the health of affected. Given that DSS is a large-scale hazard, to gain preparedness, countries should move towards regional and international cooperation. The health system needs to develop a comprehensive plan of readiness to improve the effectiveness of the response measures. Also, regular exercises in all scales are a very important component. To increase public health recommended the development of dust-health EWS. Promotion of preparedness culture and the increase of public awareness about the effects of DSS through public media are suggested. In preparedness programs, the participation of the community is recommended. Health workers should receive regular training on cardiovascular and respiratory problems. Further quantitative and qualitative researches to identify the nature of DSS and adaptive factors can help bridge the gap between scientific findings and preparedness measures. Although we addressed preparedness in this study, there should be a comprehensive plan to manage the hazard and to consider all the loops of the disaster risk management cycle. In general, this study can help policy-makers of the health system in disaster risk management to identify factors that are effective in preparedness for DSS and to take the necessary preparedness measures.

 Data availability

All data underlying the results are available as part of the article and no additional source data are required.

 Reporting guidelines

A completed PRISMA checklist is available on figshare, DOI: https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.7581833 30 .

License: CC0 1.0 Universal.

This study is the result of the dissertation of the PhD in the School of Public Health and Safety, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran. Current study was approved by the Ethics Committee in Biomedical Research of Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran, with the ethical code of IR.SBMU.RETECH.1396.1149.

 EM-DAT: The International Disaster Database, Centre for Research on the Epidemiology of Disasters- RECRED. Reference Source The Disasters classification used in EM-DAT is based on and adapted from the he IRDR Peril Classification and hazard Glossary. DATA Project Report #2, March 2014. Reference Source Shao Y Wyrwoll KH Chappell A : Dust cycle: An emerging core theme in Earth system science. Aeolian Res. 2011;2:181–204. 10.1016/j.aeolia.2011.02.001 Mahowald NM Kloster S Engelstaedter S : Observed 20th century desert dust variability: Impact on climate and biogeochemistry. Atmos Chem Phys. 2010;10(22):10875–93. 10.5194/acp-10-10875-2010 De Longueville F Hountondji YC Henry S : What do we know about effects of desert dust on air quality and human health in West Africa compared to other regions? Sci Total Environ. 2010;409(1):1–8. 20934742 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2010.09.025 Giannadaki D Pozzer A Lelieveld J : Modeled global effects of airborne desert dust on air quality and premature mortality. Atmos Chem Phys. 2014;14(2):957–68. 10.5194/acp-14-957-2014 Zhang X Zhao L Tong DQ : A systematic review of global desert dust and associated human health effects. Atmosphere. 2016;7(12):158. 10.3390/atmos7120158 Goudie AS : Desert dust and human health disorders. Environ int. 2014;63:101–13. 24275707 10.1016/j.envint.2013.10.011 The WHO Regional Office for the Eastern Mediterranean. Reference Source Pachauri RK Reisinger A : IPCC fourth assessment report. IPCC, Geneva.2007;2007. Reference Source Message from the Regional Director. Reference Source Rana AK Pandey DJ : Higher Education in Disaster Management: Educating Built Environment Professions to Reduce Damage. the international emergency management society journal.71. UNISDR (United Nations International Strategy for Disaster Reduction): 2015: Sendai framework for disaster risk reduction 2015–2030.2015; Accessed 6 Jun 2015. Reference Source Martinelli N Olivieri O Girelli D : Air particulate matter and cardiovascular disease: a narrative review. Eur J Intern Med. 2013;24(4):295–302. 23647842 10.1016/j.ejim.2013.04.001 Tao Y An X Sun Z : Association between dust weather and number of admissions for patients with respiratory diseases in spring in Lanzhou. Sci Total Environ. 2012;423:8–11. 22386996 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2012.01.064 Tam WW Wong TW Wong AH : Effect of dust storm events on daily emergency admissions for respiratory diseases. Respirology. 2012;17(1):143–8. 22092966 10.1111/j.1440-1843.2011.02056.x Khaniabadi YO Daryanoosh SM Amrane A : Impact of Middle Eastern Dust storms on human health. Atmos Pollut Res. 2017;8(4):606–13. 10.1016/j.apr.2016.11.005 Al-Taiar A Thalib L : Short-term effect of dust storms on the risk of mortality due to respiratory, cardiovascular and all-causes in Kuwait. Int J Biometeorol. 2014;58(1):69–77. 23329278 10.1007/s00484-012-0626-7 Miri A Ahmadi H Ghanbari A : Dust storms impacts on air pollution and public health under hot and dry climate. Int J Energy Environ. 2007;2(1):101–5. Reference Source Neophytou AM Yiallouros P Coull BA : Particulate matter concentrations during desert dust outbreaks and daily mortality in Nicosia, Cyprus. J Expo Sci Environ Epidemiol. 2013;23(3):275. 23423218 10.1038/jes.2013.10 Coppola DP : Introduction to international disaster management. Elsevier.2006. Reference Source Asghar S Alahakoon D Churilov L : A comprehensive conceptual model for disaster management. J Human Assist. 2006;1360(0222):1–15. Reference Source Khan H Vasilescu LG Khan A : Disaster management cycle-a theoretical approach. J Manage Mark. 2008;6(1):43–50. Reference Source Pelfrey WV : The cycle of preparedness: Establishing a framework to prepare for terrorist threats. J Homel Secur Emerg. 2005;2(1). 10.2202/1547-7355.1081 Disaster preparedness cycle. Reference Source Kent R : Disaster Preparedness - 2nd Edition (DHA/UNDRO - DMTP - UNDP).66. Reference Source World Health Organization: Risk reduction and emergency preparedness: WHO six-year strategy for the health sector and community capacity development.2007. Reference Source World Health Organization: Health sector emergency preparedness guide: Making a difference to vulnerability. Geneva: WHO.1998;114. Reference Source Moher D Liberati A Tetzlaff J : Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. Ann Intern Med. 2009;151(4):264–9. 19622511 10.7326/0003-4819-151-4-200908180-00135 Allahbakhshi K Khorasani-Zavareh D Jazani RK : PRISMA 2009 checklist.word.doc. figshare. Figure.2019. http://www.doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.7581833.v3 Higgins JPT Green S : Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions version 5.1. 0. The Cochrane Collaboration. 2011;2015. Reference Source Miri A Ahmadi H Panjehkeh N, editors : Dust Storms Impact on Air pollution and public Health: A Case Study in Iran. WSEAS International Conferences;2007. Reference Source Meibodi AE Abdoli G Taklif A : Economic Modeling of the Regional Polices to Combat Dust Phenomenon by Using Game Theory. Proc Econ Financ. 2015;24:409–18. 10.1016/S2212-5671(15)00697-8 Geravandi S Sicard P Khaniabadi YO : A comparative study of hospital admissions for respiratory diseases during normal and dusty days in Iran. Environ Sci Pollut Res Int. 2017;24(22):18152–9. 28631126 10.1007/s11356-017-9270-4 Naimabadi A Ghadiri A Idani E : Chemical composition of PM 10 and its in vitro toxicological impacts on lung cells during the Middle Eastern Dust (MED) storms in Ahvaz, Iran. Environ Pollut. 2016;211:316–24. 26774778 10.1016/j.envpol.2016.01.006 Neisi A Vosoughi M Idani E : Comparison of normal and dusty day impacts on fractional exhaled nitric oxide and lung function in healthy children in Ahvaz, Iran. Environ Sci Pollut Res Int. 2017;24(13):12360–71. 28357800 10.1007/s11356-017-8853-4 Khaniabadi YO Fanelli R De Marco A : Hospital admissions in Iran for cardiovascular and respiratory diseases attributed to the Middle Eastern Dust storms. Environ Sci Pollut R. 2017;24(20):1–9. 28573562 10.1007/s11356-017-9298-5 Amarloei A Jonidi Jafari A Mahabadi HA : Investigation on the lung function of general population in Ilam, west of Iran, as a city exposed to dust storm. Glob J Health Sci. 2015;7(3):298–308. 25948466 10.5539/gjhs.v7n3p298 4802153 Thalib L Al-Taiar A : Dust storms and the risk of asthma admissions to hospitals in Kuwait. Sci Total Environ. 2012;433:347–51. 22819885 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2012.06.082 Marzouni MB Alizadeh T Banafsheh MR : A comparison of health impacts assessment for PM 10 during two successive years in the ambient air of Kermanshah, Iran. Atmos Pollut Res. 2016;7(5):768–74. 10.1016/j.apr.2016.04.004 Goudarzi G Daryanoosh S Godini H : Health risk assessment of exposure to the Middle-Eastern Dust storms in the Iranian megacity of Kermanshah. Public Health. 2017;148:109–16. 28475960 10.1016/j.puhe.2017.03.009 Al-Dabbas MA Abbas MA Al-Khafaji RM : Dust storms loads analyses—Iraq. Arab J Geosci. 2012;5(1):121–31. 10.1007/s12517-010-0181-7 Khaefi M Geravandi S Hassani G : Association of particulate matter impact on prevalence of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in Ahvaz, southwest Iran during 2009–2013. Aerosol Air Qual Res. 2017;17(1):230–7. 10.4209/aaqr.2015.11.0628 Bener A Abdulrazzaq YM Al-Mutawwa J : Genetic and environmental factors associated with asthma. Hum Biol. 1996;68(3):405–14. 8935321 Ebrahimi SJ Ebrahimzadeh L Eslami A : Effects of dust storm events on emergency admissions for cardiovascular and respiratory diseases in Sanandaj, Iran. J Environ Health Sci Eng. 2014;12(1):110. 26322233 10.1186/s40201-014-0110-x 4551887 Soleimani Z Goudarzi G Naddafi K : Determination of culturable indoor airborne fungi during normal and dust event days in Ahvaz, Iran. Aerobiologia. 2013;29(2):279–90. 10.1007/s10453-012-9279-6 Shabankarehfard E Ostovar A Farrokhi S : Air- and Dust-Borne Fungi in Indoor and Outdoor Home of Allergic Patients in a Dust-Storm-Affected Area. Immunol Invest. 2017;46(6):577–89. 28742415 10.1080/08820139.2017.1322102 Alghamdi MA : Characteristics and Risk Assessment of Heavy Metals in Airborne PM10 from a Residential Area of Northern Jeddah City, Saudi Arabia. Pol J Environ Stud. 2016;25(3):939–949. 10.15244/pjoes/61531 Moradian MJ Rastegarfar B Rastegar MR : Tehran dust storm early warning system: corrective measures. PLoS Curr. 2015;7: pii: ecurrents.dis.14f3c645eb2e2003a44c6efd22c23f5e. 25774324 10.1371/currents.dis.14f3c645eb2e2003a44c6efd22c23f5e 4347995 Almasi A Bakhshi S Pirsaheb M : Effects of air pollution caused by particulate matter (PM 10) on tourism industry and road accidents-case study: Kermanshah, Iran (2008-2013). Acta Med Mediterr. 2016;32:1951–4. Reference Source Richer R Banack SA Metcalf JS : The persistence of cyanobacterial toxins in desert soils. J Arid Environ. 2015;112:134–9. 10.1016/j.jaridenv.2014.01.023 Metcalf JS Richer R Cox PA : Cyanotoxins in desert environments may present a risk to human health. Sci Total Environ. 2012;421–422:118–23. 22369867 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2012.01.053 Alangari AA Riaz M Mahjoub MO : The effect of sand storms on acute asthma in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. Ann Thorac Med. 2015;10(1):29–33. 25593604 4286841 Mohammad MSA : Dust storm phenomena and their environmental impacts in Kuwait. University of Glasgow;1989. Reference Source Nourmoradi H Moradnejadi K Moghadam FM : The Effect of Dust Storm on the Microbial Quality of Ambient Air in Sanandaj: A City Located in the West of Iran. Glob J Health Sci. 2015;7(7 Spec No):114. 26153211 10.5539/gjhs.v7n7p114 4803936 Soleimani Z Goudarzi G Sorooshian A : Impact of Middle Eastern dust storms on indoor and outdoor composition of bioaerosol. Atmos Environ. 2016;138:135–43. 10.1016/j.atmosenv.2016.05.023 Hosseini G Teymouri P Shahmoradi B : Determination of the Concentration and Composition of PM10 during the Middle Eastern Dust Storms in Sanandaj, Iran. J Res Health Sci. 2015;15(3):182–8. 26411665 Alharbi A El-Taher A : Measurement of Natural Radioactivity and Radiation Hazard Indices for Dust Storm Samples from Qassim Region, Saudi Arabia. Life Sci J. 2014;11(9). Reference Source Hamadneh HS Ababneh ZQ Hamasha KM : The radioactivity of seasonal dust storms in the Middle East: the May 2012 case study in Jordan. J Environ Radioact. 2015;140:65–9. 25461517 10.1016/j.jenvrad.2014.11.003 Alolayan MA Brown KW Evans JS : Source apportionment of fine particles in Kuwait City. Sci Total Environ. 2013;448:14–25. 23270730 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2012.11.090 Jassim MS Coskuner G : Assessment of spatial variations of particulate matter (PM 10 and PM 2.5) in Bahrain identified by air quality index (AQI). Arab J Geosci. 2017;10(1):19. 10.1007/s12517-016-2808-9 Lim CC Thurston GD Shamy M : Temporal variations of fine and coarse particulate matter sources in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia. J Air Waste Manag Assoc. 2018;68(2):123–138. (just-accepted). 28635552 10.1080/10962247.2017.1344158 5752622 Tsiouri V Kakosimos KE Kumar P : Concentrations, sources and exposure risks associated with particulate matter in the Middle East Area—a review. Air Qual Atmos Health. 2015;8(1):67–80. 10.1007/s11869-014-0277-4 Ardalan A Mowafi H Khoshsabeghe HY : Impacts of natural hazards on primary health care facilities of Iran: a 10-year retrospective survey. PLoS Curr. 2013;5: pii: ecurrents.dis.ccdbd870f5d1697e4edee5eda12c5ae6. 23863871 10.1371/currents.dis.ccdbd870f5d1697e4edee5eda12c5ae6 3710672 Shaw R Izumi T Shi P : Asia science technology status for disaster risk reduction. Integrated Research on Disaster Risk (IRDR);2016. Reference Source Ardalan A Kandi M Talebian MT : Hospitals safety from disasters in I.R.iran: the results from assessment of 224 hospitals. PLoS Curr. 2014;6: pii: ecurrents.dis.8297b528bd45975bc6291804747ee5db. 24596661 10.1371/currents.dis.8297b528bd45975bc6291804747ee5db 3938570 Organization WH: Hospital safety index: Guide for evaluators.2015. Reference Source Ardalan A Keleh MK Saberinia A : 2015 estimation of hospitals safety from disasters in IR Iran: the results from the assessment of 421 hospitals. PLoS One. 2016;11(9):e0161542. 27602564 10.1371/journal.pone.0161542 5014380 Maleki H Sorooshian A Goudarzi G : Temporal profile of PM 10 and associated health effects in one of the most polluted cities of the world (Ahvaz, Iran) between 2009 and 2014. Aeolian Res. 2016;22:135–40. 28491152 10.1016/j.aeolia.2016.08.006 5422000 ISDR U , editor: Hyogo framework for action 2005-2015: building the resilience of nations and communities to disasters. Extract from the final report of the World Conference on Disaster Reduction (A/CONF 206/6). The United Nations International Strategy for Disaster Reduction Geneva.2005. Reference Source Guha-Sapir D Vos F Below R : Annual disaster statistical review 2011: the numbers and trends. Centre for Research on the Epidemiology of Disasters (CRED).2012. Reference Source Woodruff RE McMichael T Butler C : Action on climate change: the health risks of procrastinating. Aust N Z J Public Health. 2006;30(6):567–71. 17209275 10.1111/j.1467-842X.2006.tb00788.x Blashki G Armstrong G Berry HL : Preparing health services for climate change in Australia. Asia Pac J Public Health. 2011;23(2 Suppl):133S–43S. 21447548 10.1177/1010539510395121 Perry RW Lindell MK Tierney KJ : Facing the unexpected: Disaster preparedness and response in the United States. Joseph Henry Press;2001. 10.17226/9834 Asfaw A Admassie A : The role of education on the adoption of chemical fertiliser under different socioeconomic environments in Ethiopia. Agric Econ. 2004;30(3):215–28. 10.1016/j.agecon.2002.12.002 Damluji NN : Imperialism reconfigured: the cultural interpretations of the keffiyeh.2010. Reference Source Keffiyeh. accessed on 30 October 2018. Reference Source. Murena F : Measuring air quality over large urban areas: development and application of an air pollution index at the urban area of Naples. Atmos Environ. 2004;38(36):6195–202. 10.1016/j.atmosenv.2004.07.023 Wiggs GFS O'Hara S Wegerdt J : The dynamics and characteristics of aeolian dust in dryland Central Asia: possible impacts on human exposure and respiratory health in the Aral Sea basin. Geophys J Roy Astron Soc. 2003;169(2):142–57. 10.1111/1475-4959.04976 Bennion P Hubbard R O'Hara S : The impact of airborne dust on respiratory health in children living in the Aral Sea region. Int J Epidemiol. 2007;36(5):1103–10. 17911152 10.1093/ije/dym195 Yang CY Cheng MH Chen CC : Effects of Asian dust storm events on hospital admissions for congestive heart failure in Taipei, Taiwan. J Toxicol Environ Health A. 2009;72(5):324–8. 19184748 10.1080/15287390802529880 Schwartz J Norris G Larson T : Episodes of high coarse particle concentrations are not associated with increased mortality. Environ Health Perspect. 1999;107(5):339–42. 10210688 10.1289/ehp.99107339 1566434 Lee H Honda Y Lim YH : Effect of Asian dust storms on mortality in three Asian cities. Atmos Environ. 2014;89:309–17. 10.1016/j.atmosenv.2014.02.048 10.5256/f1000research.19185.r46125 Reviewer response for version 1 Hamadeh Randah R 1 Referee Department of Family and Community Medicine, College of Medicine and Medical Sciences, Arabian Gulf University, Manama, Bahrain

Competing interests: No competing interests were disclosed.

 25 3 2019 Copyright: © 2019 Hamadeh RR 2019 This is an open access peer review report distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Licence, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. recommendation approve

General 

The paper tackles an important topic on preparedness for dust and sand storm, a common phenomenon in the EMR that has not been much studied. The authors have done a systematic review on the topic and reviewed 30 articles in a comprehensive manner. I have some specific comments:  

Abstract

Expand results section and reduce methods.

Line 2: “Numerous health problems caused by DSS will be severely affected regions”: Something missing in the statement.

Line 2, results: The preparedness components were divided into three and ten main categories and subcategories: Revise to “The preparedness components were divided into three main categories and ten subcategories”.

 Introduction

The introduction is concise and organized, however I feel that that the last lines “The findings of the study, with proposed recommendations, can directly help health policymakers in preparedness promotion for this phenomenon, pave the way for further studies, and add to the richness of the current knowledge” better be moved to discussion.

 . Results

“Using of keffiyeh” in end of results, better to write what it means in brackets (Arab Headdress).

 Discussion

Move some parts of the discussion to the introduction where they are more relevant particularly from the first paragraph.

The authors can also mention in the limitations that some articles might have been published in local scientific journals that are not indexed and thus were missed from the review.

Are the rationale for, and objectives of, the Systematic Review clearly stated?

Yes

Is the statistical analysis and its interpretation appropriate?

Not applicable

Are sufficient details of the methods and analysis provided to allow replication by others?

Yes

Are the conclusions drawn adequately supported by the results presented in the review?

Yes

Reviewer Expertise:

NA

I confirm that I have read this submission and believe that I have an appropriate level of expertise to confirm that it is of an acceptable scientific standard.

 10.5256/f1000research.19185.r43965 Reviewer response for version 1 Moghadamnia Mohamad Taghi 1 Referee Department of Medical-Surgical Nursing, School of Nursing and Midwifery, Guilan University of Medical Sciences, Rasht, Iran

Competing interests: No competing interests were disclosed.

 13 3 2019 Copyright: © 2019 Moghadamnia MT 2019 This is an open access peer review report distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Licence, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. recommendation approve

In this article, the authors survey preparedness components of health systems in the Eastern Mediterranean Region for effective responses to dust and sand storms using a systematic review approach. It addresses an important topic, especially the preparedness of health system in Eastern Mediterranean Region. Regarding climate change, increasing temperatures and dust storms, awareness of the readiness and response of health providers is important. In this systematic review, the authors attempted to study the studies carried out in this regard.

Below are more specific comments:

In the abstract, the authors have paid too much attention to the methods, and the results are very limited and incomplete.

The keyword “reediness” is wrong, it would be better to write "readiness”.

A large part of the material written at the beginning of the discussion section is related to the introduction, and it would be better to move that section. It is recommended that the authors, after a brief description of the subject framework, focused on the findings of their study and then compare them with the findings of others.

In the conclusion, the authors must clearly and explicitly state the message of their study.

Are the rationale for, and objectives of, the Systematic Review clearly stated?

Yes

Is the statistical analysis and its interpretation appropriate?

Not applicable

Are sufficient details of the methods and analysis provided to allow replication by others?

Yes

Are the conclusions drawn adequately supported by the results presented in the review?

Yes

Reviewer Expertise:

Disaster Medicine

I confirm that I have read this submission and believe that I have an appropriate level of expertise to confirm that it is of an acceptable scientific standard.