Keywords
SMES, Latin America, profitability, costs, production
The micro, small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) play a pivotal role in the Latin America economy, creating jobs, boosting local economic activity and contribute to the socio-economic development of the region. The purpose is to reflect on the current costs management prices, the common challenges faced by SMEs in the region, and effective strategies to improve the profitability and sustainability of these companies.
it is addressed as a review study of type reflective, which used the dialectic as a method for the construction of the speech, based on techniques of triangulation of information.
in order to obtain the results, these study topics were pre-selected: (a) determinants of the costs of production in the SMES, b) strategies for the reduction and control of production costs, and c) impact of production costs on the profitability of SMES.
the present research article delves into the pivotal factors influencing production costs within microenterprises and small businesses situated in the Latin American context. This study posits that the determinants underpinning these costs encompass a spectrum of elements including but not limited to labor, raw materials and supplies, energy and utilities, infrastructure and logistics, regulatory frameworks, and administrative intricacies. Furthermore, the intricate interplay of technology adoption and innovative capabilities is also recognized as a crucial facet in this cost determination paradigm. The overarching understanding underscores the direct and substantial influence of these multifaceted determinants on the operational expenditure of microenterprises and small businesses.
SMES, Latin America, profitability, costs, production
The micro, small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) play a pivotal role in the Latin America economy, creating jobs, boosting local economic activity and contribute to the socio-economic development of the region (Ahedo Santisteban and Brunet Icart, 2011). However, these companies often face several challenges that affect their profitability and long-term sustainability, with one of the key factors influencing their ability to generate profits being the efficient management of production costs.
Now, in the Latin America context, the SMES face a series of specific conditions that may hamper their success in the market (Montoya, Montoya and Castellanos, 2010); among these challenges are: a) lack of access to adequate funding, (b) competition with larger companies, (c) market volatility, d) lack of infrastructure, and (e) the regulatory burden (Astudillo Cerón, 2008; Chirinos Araque et al., 2018; Pereira Bolaños, 2019). However, other challenges faced by the SMEs in the region, they are associated with having to operate with tight profit margins and a limited ability to absorb increases in production costs (Hernández, Marulanda and Lopez, 2014; Salas Álvarez et al. 2020; Carvache-Franco et al., 2022).
In this sense, we must recognize that production costs include various items, such as the costs of raw materials, labor, rental of facilities, energy, transportation, and compliance with regulations (Chacón, 2009; Pérez-Orozco, Montoya and Martínez-Villavicencio, 2021). For this reason, the capacity of the SMEs to efficiently manage these costs is essential to maintain its competitiveness and profitability in the market (Jiménez Arias, Arce Gutierrez and Faith-Vargas, 2022); however, the inherent limitations of these companies, as the lack of economies of scale and limited access to advanced technologies can hinder their ability to effectively reduce and control the cost of production (Fernández and Plata de Plata, 2006).
Given this context, it is necessary to understand that the impact of the costs of production in the profitability of the SMES has significant implications in terms of economic and social (Cardona Acevedo and Gutiérrez Osa, 2010). In first place, an inefficient management of the costs you can reduce the profit margins and the ability of reinvestment of microenterprises and small businesses, which limits their growth and expansion (Avendaño Castro, Rueda Vera and Paz Montes, 2016); toothers, this can affect the financial stability of the business and its ability to withstand periods of economic recession or external shocks (Leal and Labarca, 2012). In the second place, a return to limited may hinder the generation of employment and the development of skills, which in turn negatively impacts on the well-being of workers and local communities (Pozo, 2007; Jaimes-Carrillo and Rojas-López, 2015).
Made this caveat, it is understood that the impact of the costs of production in the MSES of Latin America has significant implications in both economic and social (Muñoz Cardona, and Mayor López, 2015). In economic terms, a return to limited can hinder investment, expansion and job creation, which in turn could restrict the economic development and poverty reduction in the region (Franco, Gomez and Serrano, 2019), but, in addition, the difficulties of maintaining profitability can increase the vulnerability of SMES and their ability to face crises and external shocks.
For this reason, past research has pointed out that SMEs in Latin America tend to face difficulties mainly related to production costs (Pérez Hasbun, 2008); where it is evident that among the factors involved are: a) lack of economies of scale, b) lack of financial resources, c) lack of access to efficient technology and d) limited bargaining power with suppliers can make production costs particularly burdensome for these companies (Fernández, 2008; Acosta, Pérez and Hernández 2009; Michalus and Hernández Pérez, 2012). These preliminary studies help to identify which and how these challenges may negatively affect their profitability and, ultimately, their survival in the market.
In light of the approaches described above, it is acknowledged that the research is justified by the relevance of understanding the challenges that production costs represent for the profitability of SMEs in Latin America, due to their importance in economic development and employment generation in the region. In addition, the scarce existing research on this specific topic in the scientific literature makes it necessary to address it in a comprehensive manner, analyzing the determinants of costs, the strategies for their reduction and control, as well as their social and economic impact. The intention is to provide a discussion on the knowledge base to strengthen the micro and small business sector, promote its sustainable growth and contribute to economic and social development in Latin America.
Therefore, in this paper we will conduct a comprehensive review of the existing literature on production costs and their effect on the profitability of SMEs in Latin America. The main objective is to reflect on current cost management practices, common challenges faced by SMEs in the region and effective strategies to improve the profitability and sustainability of these companies.
Embedded within this investigation is an examination characterized by a reflective research design. The dialectic method, as explained by Ortiz Torres (2011), “constitutes a resource of great potential heuristics in educational research because it allows you to reflect the complexity of the phenomena and formation processes in their entirety, in their development and in their relationships and interactions” (p. 24). This approach possesses the intrinsic ability to encompass the intricate complexities inherent in phenomena and formative processes. It extends its purview to encompass the trajectory of their development and the intricate interplay of relationships and interactions that shape them.
Integral to this method is the creation of a conducive environment for the exchange, interpretation, and comparative evaluation of ideas. This process is propelled by a profound reflection, stimulated by the interweaving of textual sources. This interplay is facilitated through a dynamic dialogue that is underpinned by a shared horizon of understanding, as emphasized by Ponce Vargas (2018). The heart of this methodology lies in its potential to extract profound insights and illuminate the multi-dimensional facets of the subject matter. The scholarly voices of Ortiz Torres and Ponce Vargas underscore the pertinence and potency of the dialectic approach within educational research.
Now then, for the identification of the documents to be reviewed, a selective sampling was used (Martínez-Salgado, 2012), which is why fifty-three (n= 53) articles that have a direct relationship with production costs and their effect on the profitability of micro and small enterprises in Latin America are considered, reflecting on the importance of this. It should be noted that the articles were collected from various databases, according to their availability and accessibility: Elsevier, Web of Science - WoS, Scielo, Redalyc and Google Scholar (Ventura Hernández et al., 2023b).
For the constructive process of the discourse through the dialectic, we preset the topics to develop within this review, in addition, made an appropriation of the technique of triangulation (Okuda Benavides and Gómez-Restrepo, 2005), in which, we have several edges or perspectives of the same topic, to be able to achieve a common horizon of understanding, which was fundamental in the process reflexive logic of communicative action taken.
Then proceed to present the reflection that has emerged from the documentary analysis, considering the topics: a) determinants of production costs in SMEs, b) strategies for the reduction and control of production costs, and c) impact of production costs on the profitability of SMEs.
The determinants of the costs of production in microenterprises and small businesses in Latin America are diverse and complex, for this reason, they cannot be observed so disjointed, but that must be borne from a more holistic view to understand the phenomenon. It is for this reason that, within the most common are labor, raw materials and supplies, energy and utilities, infrastructure and logistics, regulations and administrative burden, as well as the technology and innovation capacity (Chiatchoua, 2021); having a direct influence and significant on the operating costs of these companies, which, often have limited resources and face competition with larger firms (Lavanda Reyes, Martínez García and Reyes Acevedo, 2021).
Carrying out a comprehensive approach to these factors, it is recognized that labor is a critical factor in determining production costs in SMEs (Erazo-Panduro et al., 2022). In this context, wages and benefits can vary widely in Latin America, depending on the country and sector; in turn, staff training and retention also have an impact on production costs (Valderrama Santibanez, Neme Castillo and Garcia Meza, 2019; Hilario Rivas, 2022). For this reason, SMEs face challenges in attracting and retaining qualified talent due to competition with larger firms and limited resources to offer competitive salaries and benefits (Baldeos, 2020).
Another factor involved in production costs was found to be associated with the availability and cost of raw materials and other inputs. In the case of Latin America, which is considered one of the richest regions due to the availability of natural resources, it is also one of the most unequal, therefore, there are phenomena related to the variability in international prices of raw materials that can impact the profitability of micro and small enterprises (Arévalo-Alva et al., 2022; Maekawa Miyasato, 2022; Pillpe Valencia, 2022). In addition, transportation and logistics costs for acquiring and distributing these materials also impact production costs (Ponce Gifted and Zevallos Vallejos, 2017).
In addition, the costs of energy and other utilities, such as water and gas, are part of the factors that represent a significant part of the operating costs in SMEs. In this sense, fluctuations in energy prices and tariffs can have a direct impact on production costs and reduce the profitability of these companies (Cotrina Llamoca and Pumarrumi Huaylla, 2020; Espinoza Espinoza, Venturo Orbegoso and Bravo Chavez, 2020). In addition, the lack of reliable and accessible energy infrastructure in some Latin American countries may also increase dependence on more expensive energy sources (Vera Correa and Florián Rodríguez, 2022).
For him, the quality of infrastructure and logistics services can affect the efficiency of productive processes in SMEs. Therefore, the lack of efficient roads, ports and transportation systems can increase transportation costs and delay the delivery of raw materials and finished products (Centurión Medina, 2015; Concha and Juscamaita, 2016; Mendiburu, 2019), which means additional costs for micro and small enterprises, negatively impacting their profitability.
In another vein, it is important to recognize that SMEs in Latin America often face a significant administrative and regulatory burden. Thus, compliance with labor, tax and environmental regulations may require additional resources and increase operating costs (Tanta Espinoza, Vilca Coaquira and Luy Medina, 2020; García Monsalve, Tumbajulca Ramírez and Cruz Tarrillo, 2021), and the lack of knowledge and experience to comply with these regulations may result in penalties and fines, which affects the profitability of SMEs (Rosales Domínguez, 2020).
This issue has allowed us to recognize that SMEs in Latin America usually face a significant administrative and regulatory burden, which is directly and significantly influenced by compliance with labor, tax and environmental regulations, which may require additional resources and increase operating costs, which along with the lack of knowledge and experience to comply with these regulations may result in penalties and fines, affecting the profitability of SMEs.
However, to improve the profitability and competitiveness of SMEs in Latin America, it is crucial to address these factors strategically, which implies seeking opportunities to reduce costs by training and retaining skilled labor, establishing alliances with suppliers to obtain better prices for raw materials, adopting energy-efficient practices, improving infrastructure and logistics services, and simplifying administrative regulations. In addition, boosting innovation and access to advanced technology can help improve efficiency in production processes and reduce operating costs. This requires government support and the promotion of collaboration between SMEs, academic institutions, and other relevant actors.
Production cost reduction and control strategies in micro and small enterprises in Latin America play a crucial role in their profitability and competitiveness (Cholán and Cano, 2016). For this reason, companies should focus their attention on aspects that involve the implementation of effective strategies, such as process analysis and optimization, negotiation with suppliers, efficient inventory management, efficient use of energy and resources, and personnel training and development (Bonilla-Pastor, 2015; Cutipa-Limache et al., 2021), with which SMEs can achieve a significant reduction in production costs.
In this sense, a key approach to reduce and control production costs in SMEs is to conduct a comprehensive analysis of operational processes (Velasquez, 2022); This involves identifying inefficient activities, eliminating redundancies and seeking ways to simplify and streamline processes, in addition to adopting methodologies such as Lean Manufacturing and Six Sigma, which can be of great help in this regard, allowing the identification and elimination of activities that do not add value and optimizing overall efficiency (Avolio, Mesones and Roca, 2011; Cruz Coria, 2021; Jasso Ramos, Aguilar Rascón and Ocegueda Mercado, 2022).
Effective negotiation with suppliers should also be considered as an effective strategy to reduce the acquisition costs of raw materials, inputs and services. In this particular, SMEs in Latin America can take advantage of their flexibility and size to establish strong relationships with local suppliers, seek cheaper alternatives and negotiate better prices and payment terms (Apaza Apaza, Marin Apaza and Cutipa Ticona, 2021; Rodríguez Suárez, Mascarúa Alcázar and Ruiz Contreras, 2022). In addition, the consolidation of orders and the adoption of joint purchases with other similar companies should be considered as a strategy to generate economies of scale and reduce procurement costs (Chacón Monterrosa, 2017; Chávez Bravo, 2020).
Following this order of ideas, it seems useful to highlight that an adequate inventory control is fundamental to reduce production costs. For this reason, the SME must continuously evaluate its inventory levels and ensure that it has only what is necessary to meet demand (Cruz Delgado et al., 2020; Prado Ramos, 2022), which implies implementing efficient inventory management systems, establishing policies, inventory rotation, and minimizing the costs associated with storage and product obsolescence (Ménez Bahena, 2019; Zumaeta-Julca, 2022).
Also, the optimization of energy consumption and other resources, which can generate significant savings in production costs. In this way, SMEs can implement energy efficiency measures, such as the use of more efficient equipment, the installation of LED lighting and the adoption of automatic shutdown practices (Cortés, 2019; Hoyos-Estrada and Sastoque-Gómez, 2020; García-Contreras, Valle-Cruz and Canales-García, 2021). In addition, involving strategies that can encompass recycling and material reuse tasks can reduce raw material acquisition costs and contribute to a more sustainable approach (Solis Granda and Robalino Muñiz, 2019).
Another fundamental strategy for the reduction and control of production costs associated with staff training and development; therefore, it is considered essential that SMEs can invest in training programs to improve the skills and knowledge of their employees, which can result in higher productivity and a reduction in errors and waste (Ortiz Useche, Rodríguez Monroy and Izquierdo, 2013; Meraz et al., 2021; Martínez-Martínez et al., 2022).
As we have seen, the strategies presented above allow micro and small businesses to maximize efficiency in their operations, eliminate unnecessary or inefficient activities, and optimize the use of their resources. In this particular, it is imperative to determine that, by improving the management of production costs, SMEs can offer more competitive prices in the market, improve their profitability and maintain a solid position against the competition (Herrera Marín, 2019).
However, the implementation of these strategies not only results in economic benefits for SMEs, but also in environmental benefits by promoting the efficient use of resources and the adoption of sustainable practices, which contributes to the sustainable development of the region and the generation of a positive image in front of consumers and society in general (Paredes-Valverde and Quispe-Paredes, 2022). Despite this general overview, it is important to note that each SME is unique and faces specific challenges in relation to production costs. Therefore, it is crucial to adapt strategies to the needs and characteristics of each company, considering its industry, size and geographical location.
In summary, this topic has made it possible to visualize a series of strategies for reducing and controlling production costs, understanding these as a key tool for strengthening the business performance of SMEs in Latin America; by implementing these strategies effectively, these companies can improve their competitiveness, increase their profitability, and contribute to the economic and social development of the region. For this reason, it is essential that micro and small enterprises recognize the importance of managing their production costs efficiently and continue to explore new opportunities and approaches to optimize their operations.
Production costs have a direct impact on the selling prices of the products or services offered by SMEs. Thus, if production costs increase, companies may find it difficult to maintain competitive prices in the market. If not properly adjusted, profit margins may be reduced, affecting the company’s profitability. Therefore, iSMEs must know and control their production costs in order to set prices that allow them to earn adequately (Giraldo González et al., 2018; López et al., 2018).
In this sense, the ability to compete effectively in the market is crucial for the success of micro and small enterprises, which is why high production costs can hinder their competitiveness vis-à-vis larger or multinational companies (Benavides Pupiales and Bolaños Delgado, 2020). In this context, understanding that, in order to remain competitive, SMEs need to find ways to optimize their costs as an essential element to improve efficiency in their processes and deliver high quality products or services at attractive prices (Bermeo Giraldo, Guisado Gómez and Valencia-Arias, 2022; Ladino Fernández, Briceño Barrero and Rodríguez Rojas, 2022); therefore, efficient management of production costs can help SMEs to differentiate themselves and attract customers, which in turn translates into higher revenues and profitability (Valencia and Erazo, 2016).
In addition, production costs also have an impact on the ability of SMEs to invest and grow, for example, if production costs are high, and absorb much of the revenue, companies may find it difficult to allocate resources to expansion activities, innovation, or infrastructure improvement, which may limit their long-term growth and their ability to capitalize on new market opportunities (Vásquez Pacheco, 2015; Leyva-Carreras, Espejel-Blanco, and Cavazos-Arroyo, 2017; González Díaz and Becerra Pérez, 2021; Hernández Peralta et al., 2021). Therefore, the proper management of production costs allows SMEs to free resources to invest in their development and improve their competitiveness.
Under these premises, it is recognized that sustainable profitability is fundamental for the survival and growth of SMEs in Latin America, so production costs play a crucial role in business sustainability, as they directly affect the ability to generate profits in the long term (Suárez Pérez and Pérez Barral, 2021; Chávez Zapata, Reinoso Pérez and Urbina Poveda, 2022). Given this reality, an efficient management of production costs not only improves current performance, but also provides a solid foundation for the future growth of the company and its ability to face economic challenges (Sánchez Barraza, 2016).
In summary, production costs have a significant impact on the profitability of micro and small enterprises in Latin America, therefore, proper management of these costs is essential to ensure the sustainability and growth of these companies; that is, by controlling production costs, establishing competitive prices, improving operational efficiency and identifying growth opportunities, SMEs can improve their profitability and strengthen their position in the market. In addition, it is important for governments and other entities to support micro and small enterprises by providing training, access to financing and promoting policies that encourage economic development. For this reason, it should be understood that the success of micro and small enterprises benefits not only the enterprises themselves, but also the economy as a whole, generating employment and contributing to Latin America’s socioeconomic progress.
In this sense, the ability to compete effectively in the market is crucial for the success of micro and small enterprises, which is why high production costs can hinder their competitiveness vis-à-vis larger or multinational companies (Benavides Pupiales and Bolaños Delgado, 2020). In this context, understanding that, in order to remain competitive, SMEs need to find ways to optimize their costs as an essential element to improve efficiency in their processes and deliver high quality products or services at attractive prices (Bermeo Giraldo, Guisado Gómez and Valencia-Arias, 2022; Ladino Fernández, Briceño Barrero and Rodríguez Rojas, 2022); therefore, efficient management of production costs can help SMEs to differentiate themselves and attract customers, which in turn translates into higher revenues and profitability (Valencia and Erazo, 2016).
In addition, production costs also have an impact on the ability of SMEs to invest and grow, for example, if production costs are high, and absorb a large portion of revenues, companies may find it difficult to allocate resources to expansion activities, innovation, or infrastructure improvement, which may limit their long-term growth and their ability to capitalize on new market opportunities (Vásquez Pacheco, 2015; Leyva-Carreras, Espejel-Blanco, and Cavazos-Arroyo, 2017; González Díaz and Becerra Pérez, 2021; Hernández Peralta et al., 2021). Therefore, the proper management of production costs allows SMEs to free resources to invest in their development and improve their competitiveness.
Under these premises, it is recognized that sustainable profitability is fundamental for the survival and growth of SMEs in Latin America, so production costs play a crucial role in business sustainability, as they directly affect the ability to generate profits in the long term (Suárez Pérez and Pérez Barral, 2021; Chávez Zapata, Reinoso Pérez and Urbina Poveda, 2022). Given this reality, an efficient management of production costs not only improves current performance, but also provides a solid foundation for the future growth of the company and its ability to face economic challenges (Sánchez Barraza, 2016).
In summary, production costs have a significant impact on the profitability of micro and small enterprises in Latin America, therefore, proper management of these costs is essential to ensure the sustainability and growth of these companies; that is, by controlling production costs, establishing competitive prices, improving operational efficiency and identifying growth opportunities, SMEs can improve their profitability and strengthen their position in the market. In addition, it is important for governments and other entities to support micro and small enterprises by providing training, access to financing and promoting policies that encourage economic development. For this reason, the success of micro and small enterprises benefits not only the enterprises themselves, but also the economy in general, generating employment and contributing to the socioeconomic progress of Latin America.
The present analysis has allowed us to reflect on current cost management practices, the common challenges faced by SMEs in the region and effective strategies to improve the profitability and sustainability of these companies, taking as a starting point the elements, they share, without discriminating since business or geographic region, so that the process of reflection is still under construction.
Despite this reality, the determinants of production costs in micro and small enterprises in Latin America are believed to include labor, raw materials and inputs, energy and utilities, infrastructure and logistics, regulations, and administrative burden, as well as technology and innovation capacity, with the realization that these factors have a direct and significant impact on the operating costs of SMEs, which often have limited resources and face competition with larger companies.
In this sense, to improve the profitability and competitiveness of SMEs, it is essential to strategically address these factors, which implies seeking opportunities to reduce costs through training and retention of skilled labor, establishing alliances with suppliers to obtain the best prices for raw materials, adopting energy-efficient practices, improving infrastructure and logistics services, and simplifying administrative regulations. In addition to this, being able to drive innovation and access to advanced technology as a starting point can improve efficiency in production processes and reduce operating costs.
Furthermore, we can see that strategies for the reduction and control of production costs in micro and small enterprises in Latin America play a crucial role in their profitability and competitiveness. In this some effective strategies include process analysis and optimization, negotiation with suppliers, efficient inventory management, efficient use of energy and resources, and personnel training and development, for this reason, it is understood that strategies based on these assumptions allow SMEs to achieve a significant reduction in production costs and improve their profitability.
On the other hand, it is recognized that production costs have a direct impact on the profitability of SMEs; therefore, if costs increase without a proportional increase in revenues, the profit margin is reduced and may affect the profitability of the company, which may hinder the competitiveness of SMEs against larger companies; therefore, it is essential that these types of companies know and control their production costs in order to establish adequate prices and ensure sustainable profitability.
From this research, we understand the need to explore in future studies the impact of sustainability and corporate social responsibility on the reduction of production costs in SMEs, from where we can eo discuss how practices such as energy efficiency, waste management, and the use of sustainable materials can contribute to the reduction of costs and the improvement of the reputation and competitiveness of micro and small enterprises in a specific market.
Zenodo: Production costs and their effect on the profitability of the SMES in Latin America, https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.12786661 (Ventura Hernández et al., 2024).
The data is available under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license (CC-BY 4.0).
Views | Downloads | |
---|---|---|
F1000Research | - | - |
PubMed Central
Data from PMC are received and updated monthly.
|
- | - |
Is the work clearly and accurately presented and does it cite the current literature?
Partly
Is the study design appropriate and is the work technically sound?
Partly
Are sufficient details of methods and analysis provided to allow replication by others?
No
If applicable, is the statistical analysis and its interpretation appropriate?
Not applicable
Are all the source data underlying the results available to ensure full reproducibility?
No source data required
Are the conclusions drawn adequately supported by the results?
Yes
Competing Interests: No competing interests were disclosed.
Reviewer Expertise: small business management
Alongside their report, reviewers assign a status to the article:
Invited Reviewers | |
---|---|
1 | |
Version 1 26 Jul 24 |
read |
Provide sufficient details of any financial or non-financial competing interests to enable users to assess whether your comments might lead a reasonable person to question your impartiality. Consider the following examples, but note that this is not an exhaustive list:
Sign up for content alerts and receive a weekly or monthly email with all newly published articles
Already registered? Sign in
The email address should be the one you originally registered with F1000.
You registered with F1000 via Google, so we cannot reset your password.
To sign in, please click here.
If you still need help with your Google account password, please click here.
You registered with F1000 via Facebook, so we cannot reset your password.
To sign in, please click here.
If you still need help with your Facebook account password, please click here.
If your email address is registered with us, we will email you instructions to reset your password.
If you think you should have received this email but it has not arrived, please check your spam filters and/or contact for further assistance.
Comments on this article Comments (0)