ALL Metrics
-
Views
-
Downloads
Get PDF
Get XML
Cite
Export
Track
Correspondence

Hot topics at the intersection of aging and energetics: Diabetes/insulin resistance, Sirtuins, and the Microbiome

[version 1; peer review: 3 approved]
PUBLISHED 28 Oct 2014
Author details Author details
OPEN PEER REVIEW
REVIEWER STATUS

Abstract

A recent review in F1000Research identified the “top research priorities identified in leading publications” at the interface of Aging and Energetics. The authors identified the ten most-cited papers in each of the years 2010 through 2013, and used these forty papers to identify thematic categories. However, the search methodology used by the authors omitted many high-impact aging manuscripts. Minor modifications in the authors’ search methodology finds that Diabetes/insulin resistance, Sirtuins, and the Microbiome are also top thematic categories.

Correspondence

My laboratory members and I were excited to read a recent review in F1000Research1, entitled “Aging and energetics’ ‘Top 40’ future research opportunities 2010–2013”. The review discusses research opportunities in 10 fields at the intersection of aging and metabolism. The authors identified ten research categories through a Scopus search for the ten most-cited papers in each of the years 2010 through 2013, for a total of 40 papers. However, upon examining the list of these papers, I was surprised to notice that a significant number of these articles were reviews, and that I recognized very few of the papers. I was also struck by the relatively low number of citations each paper had gathered, as well as by the almost complete absence of high-impact journals such as Cell, Nature, Science and PNAS from the search results.

Helpfully, the authors included their Scopus search terms in the methods section of their review, and I was easily able to replicate the results of their search. Upon consideration of the search terminology, I realized the authors had limited their results to papers in which “aging”, “lifespan” and other key search terms relating to aging and metabolism appeared in the title. I repeated their search with one important difference: I searched for keywords and did not limit my search to the title field (see Methods). My list of the 10 most cited articles from each year (2010–2013) at the intersection of aging and metabolism/energetics is given in Appendix A.

The list I generated is almost entirely different from the authors’ results, including only 3 of the 40 papers identified by Allison and colleagues. My search identified many more high impact papers (based on citation count) and a greater proportion, 18 out of 41 papers, were published by the high impact journals Cell, Nature, Science and PNAS. Whereas Allison et al. identified Morselli et al.2 as the original research manuscript in 2010 with the most citations (99), my methodology identified 8 papers from 2010 with a higher number of citations, the highest of which, Ng et al.3, had 298 citations.

I performed a rapid scoring of my resulting list against the thematic categories identified by Allison and colleagues. Interestingly, “nutrient effects beyond energy” rose to the top of this list, due in part to my inclusion of metformin-related papers in this category. A new thematic area, Diabetes/insulin resistance, was tied for second place with Mitochondria, reactive oxygen species, and cellular energetics. This was followed by another new thematic area, “Sirtuins”, tied with “Calorie restriction”. The Microbiome was also an important new thematic area. Three categories identified by Allison et al., “use and effects of mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs)”, “accretion and effects of body fat”, and “the aging heart”, were entirely absent from my newly generated list.

In conclusion, a minor change in search methodology resulted in the retrieval of a very different list of papers than that identified by Alison and colleagues. “Calorie restriction”, “nutrient effects beyond energy”, “mTOR”, and “autophagy” are still clearly important areas for aging research. However, Diabetes/insulin resistance, Microbiome, and Sirtuins should be included in this list. The narrow search strategy employed by Allison et al. missed these important thematic areas.

Methods

I repeated the Scopus search the authors1 had performed, substituting the use of the “KEY” (keyword) field in place of the “TITLE” (title) field. The search performed was:

  • ( ( KEY ( ( aging OR ageing OR lifespan OR longevity OR senescence ) ) AND PUBYEAR > 2009 AND PUBYEAR < 2014 ) AND ( KEY ( ( calori* OR diet* OR energetic* OR nutri* OR food OR fat OR adipo* OR "body composition" ) ) AND PUBYEAR > 2009 AND PUBYEAR < 2014 ) )

For each search year (2010–2013), I then excluded review articles and removed self-citations using the Scopus tools, and then manually removed additional review articles and articles that did not involve biological research in the field of aging (i.e., consensus treatment guidelines, articles on children in developing countries, and material science manuscripts). Eleven manuscripts were included in 2012 due to a 10th place tie in citation count.

Thematic areas were annotated by inspection of the title and abstract only. Themes were taken from the list generated by Allison et al., and the following areas were added after inspection of the titles only: Diabetes/insulin resistance, Microbiome, and Sirtuins. Proteostasis was added to the Autophagy category, and Metformin was added to the “Nutrient effects beyond energy” category during the scoring process.

Comments on this article Comments (0)

Version 1
VERSION 1 PUBLISHED 28 Oct 2014
Comment
Author details Author details
Competing interests
Grant information
Copyright
Download
 
Export To
metrics
Views Downloads
F1000Research - -
PubMed Central
Data from PMC are received and updated monthly.
- -
Citations
CITE
how to cite this article
Lamming DW. Hot topics at the intersection of aging and energetics: Diabetes/insulin resistance, Sirtuins, and the Microbiome [version 1; peer review: 3 approved]. F1000Research 2014, 3:257 (https://doi.org/10.12688/f1000research.5625.1)
NOTE: If applicable, it is important to ensure the information in square brackets after the title is included in all citations of this article.
track
receive updates on this article
Track an article to receive email alerts on any updates to this article.

Open Peer Review

Current Reviewer Status: ?
Key to Reviewer Statuses VIEW
ApprovedThe paper is scientifically sound in its current form and only minor, if any, improvements are suggested
Approved with reservations A number of small changes, sometimes more significant revisions are required to address specific details and improve the papers academic merit.
Not approvedFundamental flaws in the paper seriously undermine the findings and conclusions
Version 1
VERSION 1
PUBLISHED 28 Oct 2014
Views
18
Cite
Reviewer Report 25 Nov 2014
Monica Driscoll, Deartment of Molecular Biology and Biochemistry, Rutgers University, Piscataway, NJ, USA 
Approved
VIEWS 18
Lamming comments on, and presents an alternative approach to, identification of “hot topics” in aging research previously published by Allison et al. (2014). In the original paper, Allison et al. screened title to identify the 10 most cited papers from ... Continue reading
CITE
CITE
HOW TO CITE THIS REPORT
Driscoll M. Reviewer Report For: Hot topics at the intersection of aging and energetics: Diabetes/insulin resistance, Sirtuins, and the Microbiome [version 1; peer review: 3 approved]. F1000Research 2014, 3:257 (https://doi.org/10.5256/f1000research.6008.r6807)
NOTE: it is important to ensure the information in square brackets after the title is included in all citations of this article.
Views
13
Cite
Reviewer Report 24 Nov 2014
Holly M. Brown-Borg, Department of Pharmacology, Physiology and Therapeutics, University of North Dakota, Grand Forks, ND, USA 
Approved
VIEWS 13
The observations noted in this manuscript partially reflect the subjectiveness of this type of analysis. The ... Continue reading
CITE
CITE
HOW TO CITE THIS REPORT
Brown-Borg HM. Reviewer Report For: Hot topics at the intersection of aging and energetics: Diabetes/insulin resistance, Sirtuins, and the Microbiome [version 1; peer review: 3 approved]. F1000Research 2014, 3:257 (https://doi.org/10.5256/f1000research.6008.r6563)
NOTE: it is important to ensure the information in square brackets after the title is included in all citations of this article.
Views
18
Cite
Reviewer Report 05 Nov 2014
David Lombard, Department of Molecular and Cellular Pathology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA 
Approved
VIEWS 18
This piece by Dr. Lamming is informative and concise. The search methodology and ... Continue reading
CITE
CITE
HOW TO CITE THIS REPORT
Lombard D. Reviewer Report For: Hot topics at the intersection of aging and energetics: Diabetes/insulin resistance, Sirtuins, and the Microbiome [version 1; peer review: 3 approved]. F1000Research 2014, 3:257 (https://doi.org/10.5256/f1000research.6008.r6566)
NOTE: it is important to ensure the information in square brackets after the title is included in all citations of this article.

Comments on this article Comments (0)

Version 1
VERSION 1 PUBLISHED 28 Oct 2014
Comment
Alongside their report, reviewers assign a status to the article:
Approved - the paper is scientifically sound in its current form and only minor, if any, improvements are suggested
Approved with reservations - A number of small changes, sometimes more significant revisions are required to address specific details and improve the papers academic merit.
Not approved - fundamental flaws in the paper seriously undermine the findings and conclusions
Sign In
If you've forgotten your password, please enter your email address below and we'll send you instructions on how to reset your password.

The email address should be the one you originally registered with F1000.

Email address not valid, please try again

You registered with F1000 via Google, so we cannot reset your password.

To sign in, please click here.

If you still need help with your Google account password, please click here.

You registered with F1000 via Facebook, so we cannot reset your password.

To sign in, please click here.

If you still need help with your Facebook account password, please click here.

Code not correct, please try again
Email us for further assistance.
Server error, please try again.