ALL Metrics
-
Views
-
Downloads
Get PDF
Get XML
Cite
Export
Track
Systematic Review

Application of artificial intelligence-based strategies for promotion of family planning in India: a scoping review

[version 1; peer review: awaiting peer review]
PUBLISHED 08 Nov 2023
Author details Author details
OPEN PEER REVIEW
REVIEWER STATUS AWAITING PEER REVIEW

This article is included in the Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning gateway.

This article is included in the Datta Meghe Institute of Higher Education and Research collection.

Abstract

Family planning is regarded as an essential component of public health and development in India since it promotes reproductive health, gives people more autonomy, and ensures population growth that is sustainable. Family planning programmes have an effect on women's health by ensuring that everyone has access to counselling and medical care related to sexual and reproductive problems. The incorporation of artificial intelligence (AI) into family planning strategy has the ability to ensure effective execution and greatly increase programme efficacy. In general, AI has the potential to improve the efficiency, accessibility, and personalization of family planning. However, it's essential to ensure that AI-powered solutions are developed and used responsibly, with a focus on privacy, ethics, and equity. The implementation of the government's family planning policy in the nation and the potential benefits of those AI-based applications are the primary focus of this scoping review.

Keywords

Artificial intelligence, machine learning, family planning, contraceptive use, future of family planning

Introduction

India was the first country in the world to launch a nationwide family planning initiative in 1952. The first focus of the curriculum was on the advantages of family planning for health. Family planning gained prominence as a population-stabilizing strategy only after the 1971 census.1 The project has changed throughout time in terms of policy and the execution of the program, and it is currently being repositioned to achieve goals for promotion of reproductive health, population stabilization, and reduction in maternal, neonatal and child morbidity and mortality. However, the small family norm has yet to become widely accepted in India. In 2007–2008, only around 54% of married women between the ages of 15 and 49 used birth control, and it appears that use of contraception has decreased since 2004.2

In India, family planning is considered a crucial element of public health and development, advancing reproductive health, empowering people and ensuring sustainable growth in the population. Family planning initiatives have an effect on women's health by ensuring that everyone has access to healthcare and counselling services about sexual and reproductive issues. Family planning has significant advantages that affect all 17 sustainable development goals (SDGs) and go beyond health.3 Giving family planning the necessary attention in countries with high birth rates has been shown to reduce poverty and hunger as well as prevent 32% of maternal deaths and over 10% of infant deaths. In terms of women's empowerment, educational opportunities, and long-term environmental sustainability, more significant advances would be made.4 “Every dollar invested in family planning saves four dollars in other health and development areas, including education, maternal health, immunization, malaria, sanitation, and water,” said the United States Agency for International Development (USAID).5

In India, the term “family planning” refers to a variety of methods, campaigns, and initiatives that encourage individuals and couples to decide on the number and spacing of their children after considering all available information. Given India's rapid population expansion and the challenges that come with it, the government and various organizations have placed a strong emphasis on family planning.6 Artificial intelligence (AI) inclusion into family planning policy has the potential to ensure the proper implementation and to significantly enhance program efficacy. Rising investments in new technology in low- and middle-income countries have created an unparalleled opportunity to leverage digital innovations to enhance voluntary family planning programmes. The application of AI to improve decision-making and gain new insights into family planning may have a substantial impact on programs, services, and users. The development of AI is just getting started. Practitioners shouldn't pass up the chance to use AI to broaden the reach and increase the effectiveness of family planning programs as these methods and tools are improved.7 The main purpose of this scoping review is to visualize, analyse, and discuss how AI is being used by the nation's government to implement its family planning program and the possible advantages of doing so.

Methods

The current paper is a scoping review of literature related to Application and benefits of AI based strategies for the promotion of family planning. The application of AI in healthcare, particularly in relation to family planning and policy implementation, has been the focus of studies in this scoping review. The review is broken down into the five stages listed below: 1. Formulating the question, “What are the applications and benefits of AI based strategies for the promotion of family planning?”; 2. Identifying eligible research; 3. Selecting studies for evaluation; 4. Integrating the data; and 5. Summarizing and reporting the results. This review was conducted in accordance with the PRISMA-Scoping Review extension criteria (PRISMA-ScR),8 and the review process is outlined below.

Search strategy

In addition to the databases like Embase (RRID: SCR_001650), PubMed (RRID: SCR_004166) and Google Scholar (RRID: SCR_008878) were searched. Two essential terms were used in the search: artificial intelligence and family planning. The other terms “family planning”, “digital technology”, “artificial intelligence”, “contraceptive use”, “future” and “strategies” were also used.

  • Inclusion criteria: All articles which provides the information on AI based family planning strategies and in relation with policy implementation as an aspect of public health in India, published in the English language between 2013 and 2023, were considered for inclusion in the study.

  • Exclusion criteria: All the articles published in other than English, insufficient details and out of scope was the exclusion criteria.

Selection of articles for the review

A total of 153 articles were retrieved from PubMed, Google scholar and other websites. After discarding duplicate citations, a total of 120 records were screened according to the eligibility criteria mentioned above. 34 articles were excluded at this stage as they dealt with topics unrelated to AI in family planning, 42 were excluded because of insufficient details; records published in languages other than English; and because they were general commentaries on family planning that did not specifically discuss in related with artificial intelligence. A total of 44 records were included in the final review. The details of this process are summarized in Figure 1, and these are discussed below.

0b25c413-c637-4058-b7f0-138383930935_figure1.gif

Figure 1. PRISMA-ScR flow diagram.

Results and discussion

Need for family planning in India

India, one of the most populous countries in the world (second only to China), has a sizable rural population and a sizable agrarian economy, according to UNDP 2017 data. According to some analysts' comparisons of the populations of China and India, India will exceed China in the next 15 to 20 years as the nation with the most labour resources and will also surpass China in terms of national competitiveness.9 China, on the other hand, will lose ground in the global race due to a lack of labour resources. The economy, resources, and environment are all under a great deal of pressure from the rapidly growing Indian population. Indians, in comparison with Chinese people, have a high marriage rate, a low median age for marriage, a high birth rate, a high rate of illiteracy, a preference for having boy children, a slow rate of urbanization, and a dense population in major cities. India, the second-most populous country in the world, has 1.35 billion people. Additionally, it has the fastest-growing economy among developing nations. This population rise has attracted attention on a global and domestic level due to the significant conflicts between demographic and economic development.10

From 450.55 million in 1960 to 1.43 billion in 2023, India's population increased. In 63 years, there has been a rise of 216.5%. India experienced the highest growth, at 2.36 percent, in 1974. The smallest growth expected to occur in 2023, at 0.61%.11 NFHS-V reports that India's total fertility rate (TFR) is 2.0 and that married women (aged 15 to 49) use contraceptives 66.7% of the time, with 56.5% of them favouring modern methods.12

The following are some of the main reasons why India needs family planning:

  • Population control: India is expected to surpass China as the world's most populous nation by 2027 thanks to one of the greatest rates of population increase in the world. Family planning can aid in reducing the rate of population growth and keep the nation from overpopulation.13

  • Health of the mother and child: family planning can help lower the risk of infant and maternal mortality. Women who space out their pregnancies can give their bodies time to heal in between, which can lower the chance of difficulties during pregnancy and labour.14

  • Economic stability: The nation's resources and infrastructure may be strained by a sizable and quickly expanding population. In order to make population increase more sustainable and manageable and to promote economic stability, family planning can be used.15

  • Women's empowerment: having access to family planning services can give women greater control over their sexual and reproductive decisions and free up more time for them to pursue possibilities in school, career, and other areas. Greater gender equality and female empowerment in India may result from this.16

In India, family planning is a crucial tool for advancing health, happiness, and sustainable development.

AI in healthcare

The ability of AI to quickly and accurately analyze complicated medical data with super-human precision and consistency is one of the key applications of AI in healthcare that is gaining popularity.17 AI has already demonstrated outstanding performance in a number of fields, including cardiovascular risk prediction,18 skin cancer screening,19 and diabetic retinopathy diagnosis.20 Modern AI-based techniques may now operate equally effectively on portable platforms, especially smartphones, thanks to advancements in microelectronics and machine learning. Smartphones are used by more than 4.4 billion people worldwide, making them a prime option for developing point-of-care technology.21 Smartphone cameras have been utilised in point-of-care tests for the qualitative and quantitative identification of clinically important biomarkers for diseases like HIV/AIDS and syphilis,22 herpes,23 sickle cell disease,24 male infertility,25 and Zika.26

Many low- and middle-income (LMIC) nations are hopeful that AI will help solve problems specific to the global health sector and hasten the achievement of sustainable development goals for health. This sense of hope is driven by improvements in mobile computing power and information technology infrastructure. A number of fundamental issues, including whether AI can be ethically and scientifically justified decisions on health therapies, have been brought up in relation to AI-driven health interventions.27 AI has already started to be employed for a variety of LMIC-specific health challenges, with interventions mostly targeting infectious diseases like malaria and tuberculosis. Although there are many different kinds of AI, most employ signal processing or machine learning in some way. AI based applications are commonly combined with other methodologies, most frequently signal processing, as well as with other machine learning techniques. AI-driven health interventions can be divided into four subgroups: patient morbidity or mortality risk assessment, diagnostic, disease outbreak prediction and surveillance, and health policy and planning. However, the majority of research on AI-driven solutions for global health does not outline the ethical, legal, or useful conditions for their widespread adoption.28 Although the field is still in its early stages, AI-driven health interventions may improve health outcomes in LMICs. The global health community must move fast to establish standards for development, testing, and use as well as to create a user-driven research agenda to promote fair and ethical use. Despite the fact that some of the challenges in designing and executing these treatments may not be specific to certain locations.29

AI boosts medical practitioners' inventiveness. These intelligent machines behave like people and quickly understand the language used to record medical information, text, images, bioinformatics, and financial activities. These machines can read human language for a choice that is 100% accurate.30,31 It enables a precise surgical treatment of the patient by providing essential information. With the use of this technology, it will be possible to find and collect enough reliable patient data to be able to predict patient outcomes, reduce risk during joint replacement surgery, shorten hospital stays, and improve recovery rates.32,33

Role of AI in family planning

An unparalleled opportunity to use digital innovations to improve voluntary family planning programmes has been generated by rising investments in new technologies throughout low- and middle-income nations. Programmes, services, and users may be significantly impacted by the application of AI to improve decision-making and get fresh perspectives on family planning. The development of AI is only just begun. Practitioners shouldn't pass up the chance to use AI to broaden the reach and increase the effectiveness of family planning programmes as these methods and tools are improved.34

Many aspects of healthcare, including family planning, could be revolutionised by AI.35 Here are some examples of how AI might assist in family planning:

  • AI is now able to analyse a person's health information, lifestyle choices, and other data to suggest the most suitable and effective form of contraception for them. This might improve the efficiency of birth control methods and lower the number of unintended pregnancies.36

  • AI is able to analyse vast volumes of health data to find trends and predict a person's reproductive health. AI might, for instance, forecast the possibility of infertility, difficult pregnancies, or other concerns relating to reproductive health, which could assist people in making better-educated decisions regarding family planning.37

  • Remote consultations are possible with AI-powered chatbots and virtual assistants may offer family planning services through remote consultations, making it simpler and more convenient for consumers to get access to contraception-related information.38

  • Fertility tracking is another example for the application of AI in family planning. People can track their menstrual cycles, ovulation, and fertility using AI-powered applications and gadgets, which can be helpful for individuals using natural family planning methods or those attempting to conceive.39

  • Population modeling can be done using AI. It is able to analyse demographic information and forecast population trends, which can assist governments and other organizations in developing and implementing successful family planning policies.40

In general, AI has the potential to enhance family planning's use, effectiveness, and personalization. However, it's essential to ensure that AI-powered solutions are developed and used responsibly, with a focus on privacy, ethics, and equity.41

AI is transforming the family planning in India

The use of AI-driven apps for health promotion and education can help with the achievement of many sustainable development goals set forth by the United Nations. The Population Foundation of India created SnehAI, the first Hinglish (Hindi + English) AI chatbot in the nation, taking into account social and behavioural trends in India. While offering a concealed, friendly, and comfortable setting to encourage conversations about taboo subjects (including safe sex and family planning), it gives factual, practical, and reliable information and resources. SnehAI is an inventive, entertaining, and instructive solution that enables communication and education about sensitive and important topics for demographic groups that are at risk and hard to reach. It serves as a powerful illustration of the essential potential of AI technologies to advance societal good.42

For couples who choose natural family planning, the ability to precisely anticipate ovulation at home with affordable point-of-care diagnostics can be quite helpful. The two most popular at-home techniques for ovulation detection right now are keeping an eye on basal body temperature and testing urine samples for hormones that are particular to ovulation. However, the results of these procedures are unclear, and their extended usage is exceedingly expensive. AI is used in a smartphone-based point-of-care system for automatic ovulation detection to identify fern patterns in a little sample of air-dried saliva. Using samples of synthetic and actual saliva, the effectiveness of the device was evaluated, and it was found to be >99% effective in accurately predicting ovulation.43

A study has been conducted on a mobile phone-based chatbot that is intended to advise users about family planning and contraceptives. The information in Chatbot was developed using The Population Council's Balanced Counselling Strategy (BCS). The attitudinal and behavioural aspects that influence people's intentions to use chatbot have been evaluated using the Unified Theory of Acceptance and Use of Technology (UTAUT) model of technology adoption. The study comprised 49 married or living together adults (18 years and older). According to regression analysis, having a positive attitude is the main factor that predicts whether someone will use a chatbot to get information on family planning. Therefore, to ascertain a positive attitude toward using the Chatbot, effort expectancy, and performance expectancy was used. The study has implications for developing mobile messaging services that will help mothers, couples, and community health workers learn about family planning in a secretive, interesting, and engaging manner. This is the first study that, to the best of our knowledge, thoroughly evaluates the effectiveness of a Chatbot for family planning assistance that works on mobile devices.44

In 2020, the IT company Quilt.AI examined digital content from four social media platforms using an AI tool called Culture AI to learn more about the knowledge, attitudes, and motives of young people in the Indian states of Uttar Pradesh and Bihar regarding family planning. Based on their online behaviours linked to family planning, internet users between the ages of 16 and 24 were divided into eight categories by Quilt. AI. These categories included conformists (38%), spiritualists (21%), skeptics (15%), crusaders (9%), activists (6%), persuaders (6%), moralists (4%) and experientialists (1%). They also discovered the distinctive skews on family planning-related themes on various social media platforms. The data enables individuals involved in behavior-change communications to customize their messaging to target particular young demographics. They can affect attitudes and behaviors around family planning by providing the best platform.7

Some examples of family planning applications based on AI are enlisted in Table 1.

Table 1. AI based applications for family planning and contraception use.

S.NoName of the ApplicationDescriptionAdditional features
1Natural Cycles45A fertility tracking software powered by AI that forecasts a person's ovulation cycle and fertility using measures of basal body temperature.Regulators in Europe have authorized the app as a method of contraception.
2CycleTel Humsafar46An AI-powered mobile app developed by The Population Council of India to assist women in tracking their menstrual cycles and pinpointing the most fertile days for conception or contraception.The software also offers custom alarms and reminders based on a user's preferences and cycle.
3Clue47A menstrual cycle monitoring software powered by AI that offers individualized insights and suggestions based on a person's cycle data and health background.On the basis of a person's preferences and medical background, the app can also offer personalized birth control advice.
4Ava Women48A fertility monitoring tool driven by AI that employs sensors to monitor a person's physiological data, such as temperature, pulse rate, and breathing rate, in order to pinpoint fertile days and forecast ovulation.A mobile app can be linked with the gadget to offer individualized recommendations and insights.
5Dot Fertility Tracker49An AI-powered fertility tracking app created by Georgetown University's Institute for Reproductive Health.The software employs a special algorithm to determine a user's fertile days and offers tailored recommendations based on their tastes and cycle information.

Overall, these AI-based tools are assisting in enhancing the effectiveness, personalization, and accessibility of family planning for people all over the world.

AI based family planning methods vs. traditional family planning methods

Table 2, compares AI-based family planning techniques to more conventional ones, emphasising the benefits of AI-based methods in terms of personalization, real-time data analysis, decision support, remote access, predictive modelling, technology integration, scalability, data-driven insights, continuous learning, and cost-effectiveness. Utilising cutting-edge technologies and data analytics, it illustrates the potential advantages that AI could offer to family planning programs.7,50,51

Table 2. Comparison of AI-based and traditional family planning methods.

S.NoComparison CriteriaAI-Based Family Planning MethodsTraditional Family Planning Methods
1PersonalizationProvides personalized recommendations based on individual data and preferencesProvides general guidelines and information applicable to a broader population
2Real-Time Data AnalysisProvides general guidelines and information applicable to a broader populationRelies on historical data and assumptions without real-time tracking
3Decision Support SystemsOffers AI-powered decision support tools for healthcare providers and individualsRelies on the knowledge and expertise of healthcare providers
4Remote Access and OutreachAllows for remote consultations and access to information through mobile apps or online platformsRequires physical visits to healthcare facilities for consultations and information
5Predictive ModellingUses predictive algorithms to forecast fertility, contraception effectiveness, and reproductive health outcomesRelies on historical trends and probabilities for predictions
6Integration with TechnologyIncorporates mobile apps, wearable devices, and AI algorithms for data tracking and analysisPrimarily utilizes manual methods and physical devices for tracking and analysis
7Scalability and EfficiencyCan scale and reach a larger population efficiently, providing personalized recommendations at scaleMay face limitations in scalability and reach due to reliance on manual processes
8Data-Driven InsightsLeverages big data analysis to identify patterns, trends, and correlations for improved family planning outcomesLargely relies on anecdotal evidence and limited data analysis
9Continuous LearningAI algorithms can continuously learn and improve based on user feedback and data updatesLimited ability to adapt and learn without significant manual intervention
10Cost and AffordabilityCost-effective in the long run due to potential reduction in healthcare visits and targeted interventionsCost may vary based on the availability of resources and healthcare infrastructure

Conclusions

Online platforms, chatbot, smartphone apps driven by AI can deliver precise and individualised information about contraception, reproductive health, and related topics. This can raise people’s awareness, enable them to make wise decisions, and clear general misconceptions. AI can help policymakers make decisions by analysing complicated data sets, simulating various scenarios, and recommending methods that are supported by the available research. This could assist decision-makers in developing policies that are based on data-driven insights and on well-informed decisions. Family planning efforts have made progress, but there are still obstacles to overcome, such as false beliefs about contraceptive methods. In order to ensure effective family planning services for all Indian individuals and couples, future prospects include strengthening healthcare systems, raising awareness, enhancing access, and addressing sociocultural concerns. Localisation is necessary before AI models, methods, and technology are implemented. The opportunities and problems associated to family planning and population growth differ by nation and place due to varying levels of facility accessibility and implementation capabilities to address the issues and potential provided by AI. Prior to applying AI to address population related issues, it is essential to conduct baseline studies to assess the implementation capabilities and impact of the intervention. Before to implementing AI in the family planning, policymakers should thoroughly examine social, economic, and cultural issues. Support is required for AI for population-based activities in order to produce good policy implementation outcomes. To ensure successful development outcomes, policies on family planning be linked with policies on the use of AI to population-related challenges.

Comments on this article Comments (0)

Version 1
VERSION 1 PUBLISHED 08 Nov 2023
Comment
Author details Author details
Competing interests
Grant information
Copyright
Download
 
Export To
metrics
Views Downloads
F1000Research - -
PubMed Central
Data from PMC are received and updated monthly.
- -
Citations
CITE
how to cite this article
G. Maroju R, G. Choudhari S, Shaikh MK et al. Application of artificial intelligence-based strategies for promotion of family planning in India: a scoping review [version 1; peer review: awaiting peer review]. F1000Research 2023, 12:1447 (https://doi.org/10.12688/f1000research.138006.1)
NOTE: If applicable, it is important to ensure the information in square brackets after the title is included in all citations of this article.
track
receive updates on this article
Track an article to receive email alerts on any updates to this article.

Open Peer Review

Current Reviewer Status:
AWAITING PEER REVIEW
AWAITING PEER REVIEW
?
Key to Reviewer Statuses VIEW
ApprovedThe paper is scientifically sound in its current form and only minor, if any, improvements are suggested
Approved with reservations A number of small changes, sometimes more significant revisions are required to address specific details and improve the papers academic merit.
Not approvedFundamental flaws in the paper seriously undermine the findings and conclusions

Comments on this article Comments (0)

Version 1
VERSION 1 PUBLISHED 08 Nov 2023
Comment
Alongside their report, reviewers assign a status to the article:
Approved - the paper is scientifically sound in its current form and only minor, if any, improvements are suggested
Approved with reservations - A number of small changes, sometimes more significant revisions are required to address specific details and improve the papers academic merit.
Not approved - fundamental flaws in the paper seriously undermine the findings and conclusions
Sign In
If you've forgotten your password, please enter your email address below and we'll send you instructions on how to reset your password.

The email address should be the one you originally registered with F1000.

Email address not valid, please try again

You registered with F1000 via Google, so we cannot reset your password.

To sign in, please click here.

If you still need help with your Google account password, please click here.

You registered with F1000 via Facebook, so we cannot reset your password.

To sign in, please click here.

If you still need help with your Facebook account password, please click here.

Code not correct, please try again
Email us for further assistance.
Server error, please try again.