Keywords
Children, Adolescent, Recreation, Social Vulnerability, Health Promotion, Argentina
Children, Adolescent, Recreation, Social Vulnerability, Health Promotion, Argentina
Leisure time allows children and adolescents to participate in a diverse range of activities that contribute to developing their identity, improve their self-regulation and express their interests. Several studies show that extracurricular activities benefit the positive development of the child-adolescent population1–3.
In recent decades, Argentina has made notable progress in expanding the rights of children and adolescents through the adoption and promulgation of various laws, and the adoption, and ratification of the Rights of the Child. Despite the progress made in the legal and institutional framework in 2011–2012, it was observed that 30.1% of children in Argentina were affected by multidimensional poverty4.
Social vulnerability in children and adolescents is a central element in the definition of social protection policies5 that seek to improve the quality of life in children and adolescents6 and promote healthy free-time uses7.
Today, leisure time is considered a right. This is claimed by the Convention on the Rights of the Child8, in which it is understood as a time for rest and leisure7, and it is considered a necessary element in the approach to health promotion9; but it is also one of the main social determinants of health10.
Previous studies indicate that the use of leisure time is related to social vulnerability in children and adolescents11–13. In these, it is observed that as the social stratum diminishes, the low performance of extracurricular recreational activities (sports, art and cultural) increases and the probability of not having access to this type of incentives increases14. The social inequality gap in socialization opportunities is significant and clearly regressive for children and adolescents living in poverty in Argentina14. On the other hand, gender socialization may be an important mechanism to both understand and counteract observed differences in participation in free-time activities among genders12,14,15.
The scarce evidence documented in the field explored in the Argentina and Latin America highlights the importance of the production of knowledge of the impact of social vulnerability on the healthy use of leisure time in children and adolescents in order to contribute to the quality of life and health of this group from a holistic and integral perspective.
The main objective of this study was to analyze the relationship between social vulnerability and the healthy use of leisure time of children and adolescents in urban contexts in Argentina in 2012.
This was a cross-sectional, analytical study of a secondary database of the Module on Activities of Girls, Boys and Adolescents (MANNyA)16 that was included as part of the Annual Urban Household Survey (EAHU, by its Spanish initials) during 2012. The MANNyA was carried out on the basis of an inter-institutional initiative between the Ministry of Labor, Employment and Social Security, the National Secretariat for Children, Youth and Family, the National Commission for the Eradication of Child Labor, the National Institute of Statistics and Censuses (INDEC, by its Spanish initials) and the Provincial Statistical Offices.
The sample consisted of children and adolescents aged 5 to 17 from urban conglomerates in Argentina. It was a probabilistic, stratified and multi-stage sample of 34,487 households, with a total of 25,915 children and adolescents surveyed16.
The data from the MANNyA secondary database16, the basis of this analysis, was collected using a self-administered instrument. The databases of MANNyA 2012 are public and can be obtained in the web site of INDEC.
The instrument included closed-ended questions aimed at obtaining what children and adolescents usually do in their leisure time.
"Healthy use of leisure time", defined as the time for rest and leisure activities, play and recreational activities suitable for the age. It also implies the right to participate freely in cultural life and the arts7. In the framework of the analyzed module, leisure time activities are defined as everything that the child does before or after school, or on the weekends16.
The dimensions of analysis for this study were:
- School activities (homework or studying for school);
- Sports/physical recreation (football, swimming, cycling/horseback riding, etc.);
- Art (painting, theatre, music, dance, language or art-related workshop or course);
- Socialization (going out with friends to the cinema, to the square, to the cyber cafe, etc.);
- Use of Information and Communication Technologies (ICT; computer or netbook); and
- Internet use
"Social vulnerability", defined as the situations of insecurity and defenselessness experienced by communities, families, and individuals in their livelihood conditions, as a consequence of the impact caused by any socio-economic event. In addition, the management of resources and the strategies used by them to cope with the effects of this event were considered17. Today, social vulnerability is considered one of the main social determinants of health10, where most health problems can be attributed to people's socio-economic conditions.
For the construction of this variable, a Social Vulnerability Index (SVI) was prepared (Table 1) based on the data from the MANNyA secondary database16. The dimensions and weighting values of the conceptualization of social vulnerability were based on previous publications17,18.
Dimension | Categories/Definition | Weighting *** |
---|---|---|
Overcrowding | - Households with “moderate” overcrowding (>2 and ≤3 people per room) * - Households with “critical” overcrowding (>3 people per room) * | 0.10 0.10 |
Housing | - Households with moderate housing material quality (Calmat 3) ** - Households with critical housing material quality (Calmat 4 or 5) ** | 0.10 0.15 |
Occupation | - Households with 2 to 4 members per household head employed - Households with 5 or more members per household head employed - Households not receiving any income from work. retirement or pension | 0.30 0.30 0.30 |
Health Coverage | - Households with head employed without health coverage | 0.15 |
Education | - Households whose head has an average of <7 years of schooling - Households whose head has an average of >7 and <12 years of schooling | 0.25 0.10 |
* It represents the ratio between the total number of people in the household and the total number of rooms or spaces available in the household (excluding bathroom(s) and kitchen(s)(Instituto Nacional de Estadísticas y Censos).
**The predominant materials of the constituent components of the dwelling (floors, walls, and roofs) are assessed and categorized in relation to their strength, resistance, and capacity for thermal, waterproof, and sound insulation. The dwellings are classified as:
Calmat I and II: the dwelling was made from resistant and solid materials used in floors and roofs, although it may/ may not incorporate insulating or finishing elements in at least one of these. Mosaic/tile/wood/ceramic/carpet floors were considered. The roof had a membrane/asphalt singles and did have a ceiling/interior cladding.
Calmat III: the dwelling was made from resistant and solid materials used in floors and roofs, but it lacks elements of insulation or finishing in all of these. Cement floor/fixed brick floor was considered. Roof with tile/slab roof without any cover, slate/clay tile, and no ceiling/interior cladding.
Calmat IV and V: the dwelling was made of non-resistant materials in at least one of the constituent components. Loose brick/earth floor and roofs of sheet metal without cover, fiber cement/plastic sheet, corrugated roofing sheet, cane/board/straw with mud/ straw alone were considered and there was no ceiling/interior cladding.
***In the weighting structure, greater importance has been given to the occupation dimension (dependency burden of income earners), given that the association of the population with the labor market becomes a key factor in social vulnerability, and monetary income can change the situation of social inclusion/exclusion more immediately.
The categories included material assets, such as employment and housing, and non-material assets, such as those related to human capital (access to the health system and educational system of the head of household).
The construction of the SVI was based on the selection of dimensions represented by different categories which, depending on the risk situation, were defined as «moderate» or «critical».
Since each of the selected categories may have different levels of intensity, it was decided to define differential weights within them18.
Next, the SVI of each household where the child or adolescent is living was categorized as follows: without SVI was assigned to those cases with a value of 0.00; low or moderate SVI was assigned to those cases with values between >0.00 and ≤0.45; high SVI was assigned to those cases with values greater than 0.45.
The variables of interest were analyzed descriptively using position and dispersion measurements and frequency distribution.
Given the hierarchical structure of the data (individuals grouped in regions of the country), a multilevel logistic regression analysis was conducted to explore the relationship between the social vulnerability and the healthy use of leisure time. The models considered socio-economic and socio-demographic variables at two levels: an individual level, relating to the child/adolescent (performance of domestic and economic activities, gender, age, school attendance, health coverage, illiteracy), and a household level (level of education of the head of household). An empty model (Model 0) was performed, and the level 2 variance (household) and the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) were calculated.
Firstly, a univariate analysis was carried out and, from the variables that resulted in statistical significance, a multivariate model of random intersection was constructed by introducing one variable at a time. The standard errors were calculated taking into account the cluster effect of each region of the country. The variable-addition models were compared using the likelihood ratio test. The proportion of the variance at level 2 explained (PVE) by the different models was calculated as PVE= (V) × 100.
The statistical package Stata® v14.2 (Stata Corporation, College Station, Texas, USA) was used for all the analyses, and a p<0.05 value was considered statistically significant.
The study was carried out on the basis of a secondary analysis of the MANNyA database16, compiled by different public bodies under the leadership of the INDEC. In Argentina, public statistics produced by the State are part of the National Statistical System created by Law No. 17622, which guarantees confidentiality and the Protection of Personal Data through Law No. 25326.
The database is currently public and open-access, and is de-identified by the responsible public body19. Thus, this study did not require an evaluation by an ethics committee and, in addition, qualifies for the status of being exempt from obtaining informed consent.
As shown in Table 2, the sample consisted of 52.6% males and 63.5% adolescents. In total, 32.2% of the respondents were from Gran Buenos Aires and 30.9% from the Pampas region. It is also observed that 95.5% were attending school at the time of the survey and 58.1% had some kind of health coverage.
School Attendance of the child/adolescent defined as: self-report of attending school at the time of the survey.
Health Coverage of the child/adolescent defined as: health insurance (including Comprehensive Medical Attention Program (PAMI), mutual/prepaid/emergency service). Public plans and insurance were not considered as coverage.
Child/adolescent Does Not Know How to Read or Writedefined as: self-reporting of not knowing how to read or write at the time of the survey.
Social Vulnerability Index (SVI) of the child/adolescent defined as: The SVI of each household where the child or adolescent is included according to the categories (Without SVI: value of 0.00/SVI low/moderate: >0.00 and ≤0.45/SVI high: >0.45).
Table 3 shows the prevalence of activities of healthy use of leisure time, according to socio-demographic characteristics. It was observed that the prevalence of performance of school activities was 90.1%, higher in the group with health coverage (91.9%) and in the literate group (92.6%). Art activities (21.8%) had the lowest prevalence of performance as compared to the other activities of free-time use.
The socialization, sports/recreational activities, use of ICTs and the Internet showed an intermediate prevalence between 51.1% and 74.2%, being, in most cases, higher in males than in females. Also, lower values are observed in groups that do not attend school, do not have health coverage and are illiterate.
Table 4 shows the main results of the subgroup analysis. In the group without SVI (10.9% of the sample), it was observed that the highest prevalence was the performance of school activities (90.9%), with the art activities being the least prevalent (19.2%).
Social Vulnerability Index (SVI) of the child and adolescent defined as: The SVI of each household where the child or adolescent is included according to the cohort categories of: Without SVI: value of 0.00/low/moderate SVI: >0.00 and ≤0.45/ high SVI: >0.45.
Life Stage defined as: childhood <10 years old and adolescence ≥ 10 to 19 years old according to the WHO classification.
Region of the child and adolescent defined as: Greater Buenos Aires, Cuyo, Northeast, Northwest, Pampas, and Patagonia.
Health Coverage of the child and adolescent defined as: health insurance (including Comprehensive Medical Attention Program (PAMI), mutual/prepaid/emergency service). Public plans and insurance were not considered as coverage.
Child/adolescent knows how to read or write defined as: self-reporting of not knowing how to read or write at the time of the survey.
Among those with a low or moderate SVI (87.1%), the distribution of the performance of leisure time activities was the same as that of the group without SVI, although with higher values in the cases of ICTs (75.1%), Internet (66.7%) and art activities (22.4%).
In the group composed of those with a high SVI (2.1%), the distribution of the performance of leisure time activities changes as compared to the other two groups of SVI. While school activities (83.1%) and art activities (11.4%) continues to be the most and least popular choice, respectively, sports/recreational activities are in second place (48.1%), replacing ICTs, which have moved into third place (45.1%). In turn, socialization activities (36.3%) were more prevalent than Internet use (33.7%).
In the multilevel models, statistically significant associations between some leisure time use activities and social vulnerability are seen (Table 5).
Multilevel logistic regression model (n= 25,915). Module on Activities of Girls, Boys and Adolescents, Annual Urban Household Survey, 2012.
OR: (odds ratio) obtained by a logistic regression model, where the dependent variable was the leisure time use activities (such as dichotomous).
Social Vulnerability Index (SVI) defined as: The SVI of each household where the child or adolescent is included according to the cohort categories of: Without SVI: value of 0.00/low/moderate SVI: >0.00 and ≤0.45/high SVI: >0.45.
Healthy Use of Leisure Time Activities: as a dichotomous variable (yes/no) (school, sports/recreational, art, socialization, ICT and Internet).
Household activities of the child/adolescent defined as: activities carried out in the home in an intensive and/or non-intensive manner;
Economic activities of the child/adolescent defined as: worked in the reference week and/or worked during the last year.
Age defined as: childhood <10 years old and adolescence ≥ 10 to 19 years old according to the WHO classification.
School Attendance of the child/adolescent defined as: self-report of attending school at the time of the survey.
Health Coverage of the child/adolescent defined as: health insurance (including Comprehensive Medical Attention Program (PAMI), mutual/prepaid/emergency service). Public plans and insurance were not considered as coverage.
Child/adolescent Knows How to Read or Write defined as: self-reporting of not knowing how to read or write at the time of the survey.
Head of Household’s Education Level defined as: incomplete elementary education (including special education), complete elementary education, incomplete high school education, complete high school education, incomplete college education, complete college education, and without schooling.
Employment Status of the Household Head defined as: employed, unemployed, inactive, less than 10 years.
Model 0: empty model only of random intersection of the dependent variable attributable to the region.
Model 2: individual multivariate. Model 1+ all individual variables such as child/adolescent’s household activities (intensive or non-intensive) and child/adolescent’s economic activities (worked in the reference week or worked during the last year) sex of the child/adolescent, age of the child/adolescent, current school attendance of the child/adolescent, health coverage of the child/adolescent, child/adolescent can read and write with random intersection.
In the multilevel model, the non-performance of school activities was statistically associated with low/moderate SVI, with an OR of 1.165 (p=0.023).
In analyzing the relationship between high SVI and the risk of not performing sports/recreational activities, it was observed that the OR was 1.292, although this association was not significant (p=0.088).
With respect to the relationship between high SVI and the non-performance of art activities, an OR of 2.232 was found; that is, a higher risk of not performing these activities, being statistically significant (p≤0.001). This was similarly reflected in the relationship between SVI in the highest stratum and the socialization activities (OR 1.999 and p≤0.002).
With respect to the relationship between high SVI and the non-use of ICTs, a statistically significant association was observed, in which the OR was 14.171; that is, high SVI resulted to be a risk factor (p=0.000). On the other hand, it could be observed that the non-use of the Internet during leisure time in the group with high SVI yielded an OR of 21.887, being significant (p≤0.000).
Based on the aforementioned, in the final models (Model 3), which considered individual and contextual variables, a clear upward gradient in the likelihood of unhealthy use of leisure time is observed when there are increased SVI levels in the cases of art, socialization, ICT, and the Internet.
Our results highlighted the impact of a high social vulnerability index on the reduced performance of some healthy leisure time activities such as art, socialization and Internet use, among children and adolescents in Argentina.
A new look at the concepts of leisure time in Latin America has to be constructed, rescuing the profound knowledge and practices already elaborated in Latin American territories20. However, reflection on this relationship requires various perspectives and levels of analysis. In this sense, it is necessary to highlight the influence of the public social protection policies in guaranteeing the right to leisure time in childhood and adolescence.
Some risk factors from the social sphere where biographies of children and adolescents are developed may have an impact on the ways in which they perform in society. The fact that a significant part of the risk to their health and quality of life occurs in this context was highlighted in the field of social epidemiology21.
As Feito22 suggests that vulnerability has a dimension of susceptibility to harm, conditioned by intrinsic and extrinsic factors, anchored in the radical fragility of the human being, but undoubtedly largely attributable to social and environmental elements. In this sense, our study showed that a significant part of the population under analysis had some degree of social vulnerability, which makes us consider this indicator as one social determinant of health10.
Regarding the healthy use of leisure time in the population under analysis, it was observed that some activities were more prevalent than others; generally, art, sports/recreational, and socialization activities were less frequent. This information is important because, as other authors have shown23,24, these activities should be proposed as strategies to promote the health of children and adolescents at social risk25, since they contribute to the psychosocial and physical state of children and adolescents, while at the same time promoting life skills. This fact is relevant since they could also be the activities to be promoted through different public health policies and programs in the country.
In addition, some activities such as sports and recreation were performed only by half of the sample. This leads to the need to promote these activities in order to have a positive impact on some aspects related to the physical and mental health and nutrition of children and adolescents in a complex epidemiological context, characterized by the increase in chronic diseases, low physical activity, and malnutrition26,27.
Another aspect to highlight is the high prevalence of school activities during leisure time. This can be explained by the implementation of public policies of great impact in the years prior to this survey, such as the Universal Child Allowance (AUH), in force since 200928 and considered a key element for staying at school.
In this sense, the debate on the psychosocial development in childhood and adolescence should be focused not only on school activities, but also on the possibility of choosing and performing multiple leisure time activities freely; activities that entail an enjoyment linked to them. In this sense, we agree with what Fredriksson and colleagues stated in a recent publication, in which they suggest that increasing the participation of young people in leisure activities, especially those from more socially vulnerable environments, can help to reduce social inequalities in health. In this sense, it is necessary to promote varied activities, both structured and unstructured, during free time29.
Another aspect to consider is that of gender differences in the performance of activities during leisure time. For example, it is observed that “sexual division in the activities between men and women is already established in childhood and adolescence”30. Our results showed that men tended to do more sports activities and women more art activities.
With respect to some social determinants of health, such as literacy or school attendance, in all the activities the prevalence was found to be higher in the low and without SVI subgroups, highlighting the weight of these determinants. In this sense, the ecological study conducted by Viner et al. on the health of adolescents suggested that the most effective health interventions are probably those addressing structural changes, e.g. access to education31.
Furthermore, it should be noted that the use of digital-free time, mainly focused on the use of the Internet and ICTs, has become increasingly present in the activities of children and adolescents and has become an agent of socialization32.
However, our results show that the use of the Internet is significantly conditioned by social vulnerability. In this sense, it was observed that, in the group with the highest level of vulnerability, there is a 14 times higher risk of not using the Internet. This is relevant and shows how the condition of vulnerability becomes a determinant barrier when accessing certain goods and services, especially if progress is to be made in reducing digital divides33.
Our findings on the use of ICTs were similarly, albeit less strongly, reflected in the use of the Internet; that is, it was observed that there was a risk of not using ICTs in the groups with high levels of social vulnerability. It should be noted that two years before this survey, Argentina implemented the “Connecting Equality” policy34, a federal broad-scope program. This is important because the effectiveness of the digital divide reduction policies, especially among the most vulnerable groups, could present certain barriers to access35.
There were also marked differences with respect to art and socialization practices, where it was found that the higher the social vulnerability index, the higher the risk of not performing these activities. However, this result highlights the importance of promoting this type of activity in children and adolescents, since, according to the evidence and based on the findings by Wald36, the changes perceived as a result of participating in art workshops are closely linked to feelings of well-being, the development of personal capacities and the strengthening of group relations, which may be linked in a broad sense to the paradigm of health promotion.
Furthermore, the subjective processes of socialization in human health acquires a central role. In this line, the World Health Organization37 hierarchized and gave relevance to these aspects within the concept of quality of life. Several points can be highlighted in our results and our contributions to the knowledge of the situation of leisure time use in children and adolescents.
Firstly, it was found that in 2012 there was a social inequality gap, as measured by the SVI. On this point, and going back to the theoretical framework that underpinned this proposal, it is necessary to reflect on the weakening of social networks, unfavorable economic scenarios and the differential impact of targeted social protection policies at national level38.
Secondly, the negative effect of social vulnerability on some specific activities was highlighted, such as those related to art, socialization processes and access to goods and services such as the Internet. From here, it is possible to postulate that this would not be fully contributing to the achievement of the Rights of the Child8, which claim the free participation in cultural life and the arts7.
Thirdly, it was observed that, in a large part of the activities of healthy leisure time use, the presence of social vulnerability conditions its full performance; in this sense, it could be believed that these activities are hampered or compete with other activities e.g. those that are domestic and economic30.
In a study carried out in Ecuador, Mexico and Peru, CEPAL and UNICEF stressed that work, both paid and unpaid, is another activity that occupies an important part of adolescents' time; this reality is not in line with the fundamental rights of this group30. Thus, we face a double challenge concerning the effective right to the healthy use of leisure time. On the one hand, the aim is to promote leisure and welfare activities for children and adolescents30; sports, art, and socialization activities. On the other hand, it is necessary to consider the digital divide and access to differential goods and services, which could be considered as socialization agents32 in this group.
Another weakness of the proposal is that the research question was addressed based on the analysis of a secondary data source, so it is possible that some aspects related to the construction of the SVI were left out. However, the methodology for the construction of this index is flexible and there is not a sole theoretical frame of reference. Lastly, another limitation was the data collection date (2012), where some aspects may have been modified so far.
However, this study has many important strengths. Among them, the large sample size stands out. It allowed for multivariate analyses and adjustments by multiple confounders and the national representativeness of the sample, since the survey of the secondary database was coupled to the Annual Urban Household Survey (EAHU) by following the application of a rigorous probabilistic sampling, thus ensuring the accuracy of the data obtained and the scope of the entire urban population of the country16.
In conclusion, the presence of social vulnerability has an unfavorable impact on the performance of some healthy leisure time activities, such as art, socialization and use of the Internet in the group of children and adolescents in Argentina. The obtained findings lead us to highlight some strategic moves concerning the field of health social determinants where the SVI could be a useful tool to guide health promotion initiatives in the population of children and adolescents.
The MANNyA data and documentation are available at https://www.indec.gob.ar/bases-de-datos.asp?solapa=7.
Views | Downloads | |
---|---|---|
F1000Research | - | - |
PubMed Central
Data from PMC are received and updated monthly.
|
- | - |
Alongside their report, reviewers assign a status to the article:
Invited Reviewers | ||
---|---|---|
1 | 2 | |
Version 3 (revision) 07 May 21 |
read | read |
Version 2 (revision) 12 Oct 18 |
read | read |
Version 1 09 Oct 18 |
Provide sufficient details of any financial or non-financial competing interests to enable users to assess whether your comments might lead a reasonable person to question your impartiality. Consider the following examples, but note that this is not an exhaustive list:
Sign up for content alerts and receive a weekly or monthly email with all newly published articles
Already registered? Sign in
The email address should be the one you originally registered with F1000.
You registered with F1000 via Google, so we cannot reset your password.
To sign in, please click here.
If you still need help with your Google account password, please click here.
You registered with F1000 via Facebook, so we cannot reset your password.
To sign in, please click here.
If you still need help with your Facebook account password, please click here.
If your email address is registered with us, we will email you instructions to reset your password.
If you think you should have received this email but it has not arrived, please check your spam filters and/or contact for further assistance.
Comments on this article Comments (0)