ALL Metrics
-
Views
-
Downloads
Get PDF
Get XML
Cite
Export
Track
Software Tool Article

BioSounds: an open-source, online platform for ecoacoustics

[version 1; peer review: 2 approved]
* Equal contributors
PUBLISHED 12 Oct 2020
Author details Author details
OPEN PEER REVIEW
REVIEWER STATUS

This article is included in the Ecology and Global Change gateway.

Abstract

Passive acoustic monitoring of soundscapes and biodiversity produces vast amounts of audio recordings. However, the management of these raw data presents technical challenges and their analysis suffers from bottlenecks. A multitude of software solutions exist, but none can perform all the data processing needed by ecologists for analysing large acoustic data sets. The field of ecoacoustics needs a software tool that is free, evolving, and accessible. We take a step in that direction and present BioSounds: an open-source, online platform for ecoacoustics designed by ecologists and built by software engineers. Biosounds can be used for archiving and sharing recordings, manually creating and reviewing annotations of sonant animals in soundscapes, analysing audio in time and frequency, and storing reference recordings for different taxa. We present its features and structure, and compare it with similar software. We describe its operation mode and the workflow for typical use cases such as the analysis of bird and bat communities sampled in soundscape recordings. BioSounds is available from: https://github.com/nperezg/biosounds

Keywords

Soundscape, sound analysis, ecoacoustics, passive acoustic monitoring, automated sound recording, autonomous recording units, spectrogram, audio annotation

Introduction

Automated, passive recording for biodiversity research has come of age. It presents new opportunities for ecologists, but yields huge amounts of data that are challenging to manage1. The resulting recordings are raw data that require considerable effort to extract the ecological information contained within. To realise the potential of ecoacoustics projects, different software tools are required in different data processing and analysis stages: First, soundscape recordings - comprising all sounds recorded in a landscape2 - need to be archived and made accessible to collaborators, either locally or remotely3. Sometimes, an optional pre-processing stage (e.g., re-sampling, merging and splitting, compressing of recordings) is conducted using audio editing software4. In general, recordings need to be visualized using spectrograms (i.e., sonograms) and played back to detect, identify, and then manually annotate the target sounds (usually sonant animal species)4,5. To our knowledge, no dedicated tool allows for a consistent, structured validation workflow of these manual annotations yet by independent experts. Increasingly, automated detection and classification of sounds is used to facilitate processing large amounts of audio data6. The latter still need to be verified by human experts, who rely either on their own knowledge, or reference recordings found in audio repositories (i.e., reference sound libraries) linking recordings to species identities7. Alternatively to their time-consuming manual annotation, soundscapes can be characterised with automatically computed eco-acoustic indices that can be linked to biodiversity metrics8,9, or with general acoustic feature sets that can be used to detect anomalous sound events in an unsupervised manner10. Finally, in bioacoustics- or behavior-focused studies, but also for the identification of bats, the target sounds need to be analysed further by measuring their properties in the frequency-time-amplitude space11,12. At the time of writing, no software integrates all these different data processing stages into a consistent, integrated workflow, and reference libraries are still scarce for particular species groups1.

Software tools that handle audio data need to be built sustainably to benefit a large user base in the research community. While the majority of software is free, few are online-based, many are specialised on specific taxa, and only half of them are open-source (Table 1). It is essential to have free tools that all researchers and practitioners can use, irrespective of their budget constraints. Also, only open-source projects guarantee that they can be continuously developed to keep up with the pace of technological progress, that they stay accessible over time, and that the actual functions are transparent and replicable. Within two years, three out of the 19 reported software tools by Priyadarshani et al.6 appear to have ceased development. Accessibility, which is essential for international collaboration and verification of bioacoustic data13, also requires online solutions that are mostly independent of operating systems or any commercial software. In a nutshell, the field of ecoacoustics requires an open-source, online tool, as this fulfils most requirements: being free, easily maintainable, collaborative and accessible.

Table 1. Overview of currently available software tools for ecoacoustics.

We included only ecoacoustics software tools built specifically for ecoacoustics that can play back audio and represent audio visually in the form of spectrograms. We excluded tools that were not developed in the last 2 years.

ToolSoundscape
recordings
max
frequency
(kHz)
manual
annotation
automated
species
detection
Reference
recordings
TaxaSound
analysis
Acoustic
indices
AccessLicenseInstallationInteraction
Animal Sound
Identifier
nounknownyesyesyesallyesnofree (but
requires
Matlab)
unknownpackagecommand line
Arbimonyes22.05yesyesyesall yesyesfree and
commercial
proprietarynoneGUI
Avisoft‐SASLab
Pro
yesunknownyesyesyesallyesyescommercialproprietarylocalGUI
BatSoundyes192yesnonobatsyesnocommercialproprietarylocalGUI
Biosoundsyes192yesnoyesallpartlynofreeGPLv3serverGUI
eBirdyesunknownnoyesyesbirdsnonofreeproprietaryserverGUI
EcosoundsyesunknownyesnoyesallpartlynofreeApache 2.0serverGUI
eXtensible
BioAcoustic
Tool (XBAT)
unknownunknownyesyesunknownallyesunknownfreeGPL-2packagecommand line
Ishmaelno96yesyesyesallyesyesfreeunknownlocalGUI
Kaleidoscope
Pro
yesunknownyesyes?allyesyescommercialproprietarylocalGUI
LusciniayesunknownnononoallyesyesfreeunknownJavaGUI
monitoRnono limityesyesnoallyesnofreeGPL-2packagecommand line
PAMGuardno24yesyesnomarinenoyesfreeGPL-2localGUI
Raven PronounknownyesyesnoallyesyescommercialproprietarylocalGUI
seewavenounknownyesyesnoallyesyesfreeGPL (>= 2)packagecommand line
SIGNALnounknownyesyesnoallyesnocommercialproprietarylocalGUI
SonobatyesunknownyesyesunknownbatsyesunknowncommercialproprietarylocalGUI
Sound
Analysis Pro
no88.2yesyesnobirdsyesyesfreeGPL-2localGUI
SoundIDunknownunknownnoyesyesallyesyescommercialproprietarylocalGUI
Tadaridano250noyesnoallyesyesfreeCC-BY, LGPL-
3.0, GPL-3.0
localGUI
warblRnono limityesyesnoallyesunknownfreeGPL (>= 2)packagecommand line
Xeno-CantoyesunknownnonoyesbirdsnonofreeCCnoneGUI

We present BioSounds: an open-source, online platform for ecoacoustics, designed by ecologists and built by software engineers. Currently, BioSounds can be used to manage soundscape and reference recording collections, to manually create and independently review annotations in recordings, and to perform basic sound measurements in time and frequency. BioSounds was originally based on Pumilio3 but the latter has ceased development and Biosounds has considerably expanded since. At the moment of writing, only one other software - Ecosounds - offers similar functions as BioSounds5, and we compare them with each other (Table 2). We detail the structure and functionality of BioSounds in the following and announce our development goals.

Table 2. Differences between BioSounds and Ecosounds.

We compared both software tools’ functionalities that are relevant for administrators and normal users. Both tools work with Chrome, Firefox, and Internet Explorer browsers.

CategoryCriteriaBiosoundsEcosounds
ManagementAccessibilityOpen collections available. Users
registered by administrators on demand.
Users can access all collections.
Open collections available. Self-registration of users.
Project owners can define user access.
OrganisationCreation of collections by administrator
via database. Option for collection
description.
Creation of projects by user via website interface.
Option for project image, description, and location
(visible on map).
RecordingsAdministrators can upload, delete, rename
sound recordings. Recording size limit:
300 MB.
No upload of audio files directly through website
possible; manual inspection of data and quality
control by main administrator. Recording limit: from
1 hour to 1 day (>1GB)
Reference
collection
Reference collections available with
dedicated list view. Tags can be marked as
reference.
Annotation library of animal sounds in extra
sub-menu available (1390 recordings). Tags in
spectrograms can be marked as reference.
Long
soundscapes
Spectrogram range limited by 300 MB file
size limit.
Multiple recordings can be displayed on large
temporal scales across project sites.
StatisticsOverview of users accessible to
administrator.
Statistics of annotations, projects, sites, recordings,
users, etc. can be displayed.
Playback durationLogged for each user and recording,
accessible to admin in database.
not available
GuideOnline public user guidenot available
AnnotationDatabaseSpecies names of birds, bats and frogs,
mainly of Southeast Asia, can be entered
in Latin or English. Species list can be
expanded by admins in database.
Species names and of birds, frogs, mammals and
other sounds, mainly from Australia, can be entered
in Latin or English.
CreationCreation of new annotation (tag) via
spectrogram selection and button click.
Annotation automatically created via spectrogram
selection.
EditingEditing, deleting of annotation in pop-up
window. Option to estimate call distance.
No option to copy or move tags.
Editing and deleting of annotation in main window.
No option to copy or move tags.
ReviewDedicated function for species validation
by users with reviewing privileges.
Annotations can be zoomed.
not available
IdentificationDirect link to Google images and Xeno-
Canto to check species identification.
not available
DownloadDownload by administrator through database.Download in CSV by user through
website interface.
RecordingPlaybackPlay/pause, stop button below
spectrogram. Cursor can be dragged.
Option for continuous playback.
Play/pause button below spectrogram. Cursor can
be dragged. Option to rewind, fast forward and
rewind recording (30 s).
AnalysisTime and frequency coordinates displayed
for current spectrogram or selection, can
be exported to clipboard via button.
Time displayed below spectrogram. Frequency only
displayed for selections.
UltrasoundUp to 192 kHz in Chrome and Firefox.
Playback speed can be adjusted between
0.05 and 1 x.
not available
FilteringFiltering of sound frequencies outside
zoomed selection, checked by default
(what you see is what you hear).
not available
NavigationAny part of spectrogram in time and
frequency can be navigated to and
zoomed into.
Only navigation along time axis.
VisibilityLeft and right audio channels can be
displayed separately for stereo recordings.
FFT window size set by administrator
through website interface.
No option to change audio channel or FFT window
size.
DownloadRecording: MP3 or OGG (ultrasound).
Spectrogram: PNG
Recording: WAV or MP3. Spectrogram: PNG

Methods

Implementation

Coding languages, libraries, and tools. BioSounds is a web-based application written in PHP 714, Python 2.715, Javascript16, JQuery 3.417, Twig 218, CSS19 and HTML 520. It uses Web Audio API21, Sox 14.422, Lame23 and ImageMagick24 software for sound and image processing, a MySQL25 database for organising the data (Figure 1), a RabbitMQ26 queue for file processing, Plupload 1.5 as a visual file upload tool27, JQuery UI 1.1228, JCrop 0.929, Bootstrap 4.330 and the Symfony 4 process component31 for managing the scripts execution. The Python libraries used are: Numpy32, Pillow33 and Audiolab 0.834. We containerized the project using Docker35, which spares software developers the time for installing libraries, the database, and configuring the server. This setup allows developers to run the project on their machines quickly and free of typical installation issues like library version incompatibilities.

8f51b667-377a-4934-9c58-b576bd0c1b87_figure1.gif

Figure 1. MySQL database structure in BioSounds.

Audio visualization and playback. The core sound visualisation and playback tasks are handled by two distinct components. First, spectrogram images are generated by the Python script ‘sound visualization tool’, which was created for the discontinued ‘Pumilio’ project3. This script generates spectrograms by computing a Fast-Fourier Transform on the waveform of the audio recording. Second, sound playback and speed control use Web Audio API, a high-level application programming interface for processing and synthesizing audio in web applications. It is included in modern browsers to take advantage of the browser resources without requiring any extra media player or library in our project, and we plan to use it for generating spectrograms too.

Operation

Server installation. BioSounds is published in a GitHub repository36 and needs to be installed in a web server to run. Instructions and general information regarding the setup for developers and the production server are included in the README file on GitHub. The BioSounds installation for local development (in the developer’s machine) is facilitated by a Docker setup. We provide a set of Docker configuration files that can also aid the server installation, but the final setup should be carried out by the server administrator (or devOps engineer) of the institution. For server installations without Docker, a step-by-step installation guide is provided in the repository.

Access. We run an online instance of BioSounds for our project SoundEFForTS37, where most of the steps described in the use cases below can be reproduced. This website can host public reference collections (i.e., reference audio libraries) for prospective users, for instance for Chiroptera and Anura. Soundscape collections, due to their larger size, can be integrated up to a manageable size for projects contributing to BioSounds development.

Users can access BioSounds (both the existing instance and future installations) via a desktop browser with an internet connection. BioSounds works with Windows, Linux, and MacOS operating systems and the most common internet browsers (Firefox, Chrome, Safari).

Collections. BioSounds organises audio recordings (named “recordings” hereafter) within collections. Collections can be accessed through the "Collections" drop-down menu. Those that are part of ongoing research projects are only visible to registered users; open collections are public. Collection creation is still handled directly via the database by adding it to the table ´Collection´. Administrators can then upload recordings in most common audio formats into collections. PNG image previews of the spectrograms and MP3s of the audio file are generated after insertion into the database. Audio recordings can be given names that differ from the default file name. Collections can be shown with a gallery view (thumbnails with sound names) or a list view with larger spectrograms and a simple audio player, and comments can be inserted. There are two types of collections in BioSounds: soundscape recording collections ("soundscape collections" hereafter) and reference recording collections (i.e., reference audio libraries; named "reference collections" hereafter).

Soundscape collections contain field recordings which each encompass a range of sounds from a particular site during a particular time interval. The recordings within are displayed with the gallery view by default, which shows either mono or stereo thumbnails of their spectrograms along with the sound names and the overlaid maximum recorded sound frequency (Figure 2).

8f51b667-377a-4934-9c58-b576bd0c1b87_figure2.gif

Figure 2. The default gallery view for soundscape recording collections in BioSounds.

Reference recording collections link individual recordings to identified sound sources (typically, sonant animal species). They display recordings with a list view by default; an example is shown in the public “Reference collection Anura”. Reference collections can host recordings that are needed for supporting the identification of the animals of particular taxa or regions. The spectrogram in the list view gives a rapid overview of the reference sound, and the embedded audio player can play it back directly (Figure 3). In contrast to soundscape recordings, uploaded reference recordings need to be assigned to animal species, and they can have a vocalisation type and quality rating. Reference collections can be filtered by species and rating.

8f51b667-377a-4934-9c58-b576bd0c1b87_figure3.gif

Figure 3. Reference recording shown in list view.

Reference collections can be filtered by species and rating, and additional information regarding the recording is displayed. Reference recordings can be played back directly in list view.

Users. BioSounds has two registered user classes: normal users and administrators. All registered users can open all recordings inside the spectrogram player, as well as create, view, and edit their own annotations (called "tags" in BioSounds) that are linked to sound sources (mostly sonant animal species). Normal users have viewing and reviewing privileges for other users' tags that are set by administrators for single collections. Administrators can view, review, and edit all users' tags. They can also create users, set their tags' color, and define their status (normal user/administrator). Finally, administrators can upload, rename, and delete recordings.

Spectrogram player. Recordings can be opened in the spectrogram player (Figure 4). Spectrograms are visualisations of sound where sound amplitude is shown in color or grayscale tones, time is shown on the X axis, and frequency is displayed on the Y axis. The spectrogram player offers various functionalities for tagging sounds: it is possible to play back sound, filter frequencies, navigate the spectrogram, assign selections to animal species (or other sound sources), and perform basic sound analysis.

8f51b667-377a-4934-9c58-b576bd0c1b87_figure4.gif

Figure 4. BioSounds spectrogram player.

1: sound and collection name. 2: annotating/tagging sounds. 3: hiding/showing tags. 4: playback mode. 5: moving window left and right. 6: audio channel selection. 7: overview spectrogram, red rectangle shows current view. 8: playback speed. 9: playback/pause and stop, time position. 10: playback cursor. 11: time (s) and frequency (Hz) coordinates of current view or selection. 12: copying time and frequency coordinates. 13: zooming. 14: continuous playback. 15: frequency filter. 16: utilities: image and audio download, file info. 17: tags of different users shown with different colors. 18: reviewed tags with solid border. 19: not yet reviewed tags with dashed border. 20: tags without detection distance with orange shading. 21: tag species appears on click, with buttons for editing, zooming, and estimating distance.

Use cases

Bird community analysis

Soundscape recordings can be annotated manually and reviewed by expert ornithologists, as exemplified in the collection "Upland plots dry season 2013". Users can scan recordings visually and aurally using the built-in reading mode, which zooms to a 60 s long section of the recording, including all frequencies, and enables continuous playback. All avian species can be tagged/annotated based on rectangular spectrogram selections along the frequency and time axes. Species are chosen from the integrated species list, and links to Xeno-canto and Google image searches direct the user to the selected species to support identification (Figure 5). Project-specific reference collections can also be consulted to confirm species identification. Unclear identifications can be marked as uncertain. Coordinates (in time and frequency) are saved automatically based on the boundaries of the selection. Tags can be designated as reference recordings for future inclusion into reference recording collections; comments can be inserted. Tags can be zoomed into and any of the current (filtered or unfiltered) spectrogram views (image or audio) can be downloaded for sharing with collaborators. Distances are estimated in a standardised way using a function that enables full-spectrum viewing and playback of the tags based on a spectrogram of the first 30 s of the tag. Reference audio recordings of test tones emitted at known distances are needed (see recording "Sound transmission - full spectrum" in Demo collection) to estimate detection distances in an unbiased way38.

8f51b667-377a-4934-9c58-b576bd0c1b87_figure5.gif

Figure 5. The tag editing window.

The right pane is only visible to users with reviewing privileges.

An advantage of automated acoustic survey data is that they can be validated on multiple levels, yielding accurate datasets39. In BioSounds, it is possible to review tags for validating species identification as well as auxiliary tag data. Administrators can grant tag reviewing privileges to users other than the creator. Users with reviewing privileges can either accept species identifications, revise them by suggesting other species, or reject them by marking the annotation for deletion (Figure 5). Administrators can also check the listening durations of each user for each recording to verify that all recordings have been listened to in entirety, and to extract a measure of the sampling intensity. Finally, it is possible to train users by letting them learn from other users’ annotations after granting them viewing privileges, and thereafter, to test their performance with already annotated recordings where the annotations are invisible to the user being tested. After the validity checks have been run, administrators can export the tag data through a MySQL database administration tool like phpMyAdmin40 for further statistical analysis.

Bat community analysis

Soundscape recordings that span the ultrasound frequency range (i.e., ultrasoundscapes) can be similarly analysed with the same functions as for the bird community analysis use case, but they present specific challenges regarding the analysis of bat calls. Most importantly, ultrasound is not audible, so that users need to use the playback speed slider to reduce the playback frequency to artificially hear the ultrasound calls. This can be tested with the annotated example recording "Sample Ultrasoundscape" that is uploaded in the "Demo" collection; any playback rate from 0.05 to 1 can be chosen. To aid in bat call visualisation, the spectrogram settings can also be adjusted by administrators to choose different FFT window sizes.

However, bat species identification is more challenging as bat calls from different species can be similar. Thus, we included bat morphospecies (to be exact, morphocall types) named with single letters from A to J into the species list, suffixed with digits to designate different call types from the same species. Exact measurement of bat call features (such as start and end frequency, frequency of maximal energy, as well as call and call interval duration) usually determines the assignment bat calls to specific species: using the clipboard button (Figure 4), users can copy the frequency and time coordinates of the current selection to the clipboard to perform basic sound analysis. The exported values can be readily pasted into spreadsheets, and bat call metrics of interest can be rapidly computed with formulae. For those species that have taxonomically unequivocal calls, the users can refer to the reference collection to corroborate their identifications. Finally, manual distance estimation of bat calls is impractical due to their mobility and the fact that we cannot intuitively estimate the distances of human-inaudible sounds, so that the tags can be marked as having not estimable distances.

Conclusions

BioSounds can be used to archive, visualise, play back, and share soundscape recordings online with users that have different access privileges. The recordings can be analysed collaboratively for detecting sonant animal species such as birds and bats as to derive measures of their activity for use in ecological studies. BioSounds has already been used successfully to analyse bird communities41 and to measure bat activities42, while performing basic sound analysis. Region- and taxon-specific reference collections can be created, like the anuran calls collection we currently host43.

We strive to expand the functionality of BioSounds and keep it accessible in the long term. Open access is a requirement for future development and maintenance. However, it is not a guarantee for a sustainable project either, as some of the open-source projects listed by Priyadarshani et al. in 20186 are currently discontinued projects. In Biosounds, we refactored the original Pumilio project, implemented best coding practices, and used development tools, like Docker, all of which facilitate developers’ work and help them engage in collaboration. We welcome new collaborators to support the project development who could become co-authors on subsequent versions of this article. Among others, we plan to develop the following functions:

  • Automated detection and classification of vocalisations, using existing tools44,45

  • Computation of acoustic diversity indices to monitor biodiversity46

  • Developing the sound analysis tool to include the sound amplitude dimension

  • Linking BioSounds to taxonomic databases for an exhaustive, up-to-date list of sonant animals

  • Managing and displaying geographic locations of recordings3

  • Displaying multiple recordings of single sites on a common time axis to visualise longer soundscapes5

Data availability

All the recordings referred to here are accessible in open collections without login on our online instance of BioSounds: https://soundefforts.uni-goettingen.de/biosounds/.

Software availability

Source code available from: https://github.com/nperezg/biosounds

Archived source code at the time of publication: http://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.404771147.

License: GNU General Public License v3.0 (GPLv3).

Comments on this article Comments (0)

Version 3
VERSION 3 PUBLISHED 12 Oct 2020
Comment
Author details Author details
Competing interests
Grant information
Copyright
Download
 
Export To
metrics
Views Downloads
F1000Research - -
PubMed Central
Data from PMC are received and updated monthly.
- -
Citations
CITE
how to cite this article
Darras KFA, Pérez N, - M and Hanf-Dressler T. BioSounds: an open-source, online platform for ecoacoustics [version 1; peer review: 2 approved]. F1000Research 2020, 9:1224 (https://doi.org/10.12688/f1000research.26369.1)
NOTE: If applicable, it is important to ensure the information in square brackets after the title is included in all citations of this article.
track
receive updates on this article
Track an article to receive email alerts on any updates to this article.

Open Peer Review

Current Reviewer Status: ?
Key to Reviewer Statuses VIEW
ApprovedThe paper is scientifically sound in its current form and only minor, if any, improvements are suggested
Approved with reservations A number of small changes, sometimes more significant revisions are required to address specific details and improve the papers academic merit.
Not approvedFundamental flaws in the paper seriously undermine the findings and conclusions
Version 1
VERSION 1
PUBLISHED 12 Oct 2020
Views
69
Cite
Reviewer Report 20 Nov 2020
Erin M. Bayne, Department of Biological Sciences, University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, Canada 
Approved
VIEWS 69
Biosounds is a very important step forward in the field of bioacoustics. Being able to manage large volumes of digital audio files and the various data that result is a large task that requires "big data" tools. Biosounds is a ... Continue reading
CITE
CITE
HOW TO CITE THIS REPORT
Bayne EM. Reviewer Report For: BioSounds: an open-source, online platform for ecoacoustics [version 1; peer review: 2 approved]. F1000Research 2020, 9:1224 (https://doi.org/10.5256/f1000research.29110.r74280)
NOTE: it is important to ensure the information in square brackets after the title is included in all citations of this article.
  • Author Response 07 Mar 2023
    Kevin Darras, Agroecology, University of Göttingen, Göttingen, 37077, Germany
    07 Mar 2023
    Author Response
    Thank you for your very interesting, complementary appreciation of our work. In the meantime, we have deployed a new version, adding project management, acoustic indices, phonies, maps, and timelines to ... Continue reading
COMMENTS ON THIS REPORT
  • Author Response 07 Mar 2023
    Kevin Darras, Agroecology, University of Göttingen, Göttingen, 37077, Germany
    07 Mar 2023
    Author Response
    Thank you for your very interesting, complementary appreciation of our work. In the meantime, we have deployed a new version, adding project management, acoustic indices, phonies, maps, and timelines to ... Continue reading
Views
65
Cite
Reviewer Report 10 Nov 2020
Sarab S. Sethi, Department of Mathematics, Imperial College London, London, UK 
Approved
VIEWS 65
In this study Darras et. al present Biosounds, an open source web-based platform for archiving, exploring, and tagging eco-acoustic data. The tool fulfills an important role, and provides ecologists with a user friendly, powerful tool for managing data acquired from ... Continue reading
CITE
CITE
HOW TO CITE THIS REPORT
Sethi SS. Reviewer Report For: BioSounds: an open-source, online platform for ecoacoustics [version 1; peer review: 2 approved]. F1000Research 2020, 9:1224 (https://doi.org/10.5256/f1000research.29110.r74102)
NOTE: it is important to ensure the information in square brackets after the title is included in all citations of this article.
  • Author Response 07 Mar 2023
    Kevin Darras, Agroecology, University of Göttingen, Göttingen, 37077, Germany
    07 Mar 2023
    Author Response
    Thank you for the detailed appraisal of our work. In the meantime, we have deployed a new version (adding project management, acoustic indices, phonies, maps, timelines) and addressed your comments.
    ... Continue reading
COMMENTS ON THIS REPORT
  • Author Response 07 Mar 2023
    Kevin Darras, Agroecology, University of Göttingen, Göttingen, 37077, Germany
    07 Mar 2023
    Author Response
    Thank you for the detailed appraisal of our work. In the meantime, we have deployed a new version (adding project management, acoustic indices, phonies, maps, timelines) and addressed your comments.
    ... Continue reading

Comments on this article Comments (0)

Version 3
VERSION 3 PUBLISHED 12 Oct 2020
Comment
Alongside their report, reviewers assign a status to the article:
Approved - the paper is scientifically sound in its current form and only minor, if any, improvements are suggested
Approved with reservations - A number of small changes, sometimes more significant revisions are required to address specific details and improve the papers academic merit.
Not approved - fundamental flaws in the paper seriously undermine the findings and conclusions
Sign In
If you've forgotten your password, please enter your email address below and we'll send you instructions on how to reset your password.

The email address should be the one you originally registered with F1000.

Email address not valid, please try again

You registered with F1000 via Google, so we cannot reset your password.

To sign in, please click here.

If you still need help with your Google account password, please click here.

You registered with F1000 via Facebook, so we cannot reset your password.

To sign in, please click here.

If you still need help with your Facebook account password, please click here.

Code not correct, please try again
Email us for further assistance.
Server error, please try again.